Last updated: November 2, 2026
This page explains how MalwareTips decides what to cover, how we gather evidence, and how we reach a verdict before an article goes live.
It applies to our scam investigations and malware removal guides. Our ethics statement covers the principles behind it, and our About page explains who we are.
Some older articles were written under earlier, simpler guidelines. We are updating them over time.
How we choose what to cover
Story ideas reach us in a few ways:
- reports from readers through our Report a Scam form
- ads, messages, pop-ups and websites our team comes across
- warnings from regulators, police and the companies whose names scammers borrow
- reports from security researchers, other publishers, video creators and scam-help communities
A tip is only a lead. We never treat another publisher’s report as proof, and we never copy its text, screenshots or conclusions.
Before we start, we search our own archive. A renamed product, a new domain or a tweaked subject line for the same scheme usually doesn’t get a separate article.
We give priority to schemes that are active right now and to patterns that keep catching people out.
What evidence we collect
Each article is built on evidence we gather ourselves. Depending on the case, that includes:
- Original screenshots. We capture the ad, message, product page, terms or checkout with our own screenshot service. We never take images from other publishers’ articles or videos.
- Domain records. Registration date, registrar and hosting. A brand-new domain is a warning sign, but it dates the website, not the business behind it.
- Policy pages. Terms, refund, shipping, subscription and privacy pages, compared with what the ad or product page promises.
- The checkout. Which package is preselected, the unit price and the full total. We never enter personal or payment details, and we never place an order.
- Company records. The names on the terms, receipt and business registry. The brand, the legal company and the return address can belong to different parties.
- Payment-provider rules. Card and PayPal dispute rules, so our refund and chargeback advice matches what the provider actually allows.
- Official and expert sources. Regulators, brand notices, product labels and, for health claims, published clinical research.
We keep a private claim ledger for every new or updated investigation. Each claim is listed with its evidence, what that evidence proves, and what it doesn’t.
Prices, policies, phone numbers and domains change quickly. We recheck them right before an article is published.
Lines we don’t cross during research
- We don’t enter passwords or personal details into suspicious pages.
- We don’t place orders, and we never pay to test a withdrawal.
- We don’t call or message a seller or suspected scammer unless that test was approved in advance.
- We don’t run suspected malware on our own computers.
- We hide personal and payment details in any screenshot we publish.
How we classify a verdict
We decide what kind of case it is before we write a headline. A source calling something a scam doesn’t make it one.
Every case falls into one of four groups:
- Confirmed scam. We verified a deceptive mechanism, such as phishing, a fake invoice, a fabricated endorsement, a fake support call or a malicious payment request.
- Brand impersonation. The message, ad, caller or page is fake, but the company it names is real and not responsible. We say so plainly.
- Commercial risk. A real product or seller has misleading claims, unclear pricing, hard-to-cancel subscriptions or weak return terms, but fraud isn’t established. We don’t call it a scam.
- Non-scam. The issue is product quality, a mistake, a policy dispute or a public controversy. We give the answer the evidence supports, even when that answer is “legitimate”.
Words like “Scam” or “Fake” go in a headline only when the evidence confirms the deception. A headline asking “Scam or Legit?” must be answered in the article.
Telling readers not to buy something is not an accusation of a crime. We keep buying advice separate from claims we couldn’t prove.
A verdict reflects the evidence when we checked. Websites change owners, fix problems or go bad, which is why we update articles.
New and updated investigations end with a clear decision and practical next steps, including what to do if you already paid or shared information.
Review before publication
Writing and checking are separate steps. New articles are saved as drafts first, and each draft goes through two checks before it is published:
- A structural check of headings, title and description length, links, and the source record of every image.
- An editorial review that reads the whole article against its claim ledger, including the headline, FAQ and conclusion.
An unsupported accusation stops publication, even when everything else passes. A passing automated check is never treated as approval.
Images are opened and inspected, not just counted. Each one needs a recorded source and must show the exact page, product or message the article describes.
The writer named on each article is responsible for checking it against this policy before it is published.
Health, money and safety advice
Some schemes target people’s health or savings. Our advice in these areas follows fixed rules:
- When a product makes medical claims, we tell readers to stop using it, keep any prescribed treatment and talk to a doctor or pharmacist.
- Where it applies, we list the warning signs that need emergency care.
- We never present a supplement or gadget as a replacement for medical care.
- Dispute windows differ between card issuers and PayPal. We point readers to the provider’s own rules and never promise a refund.
- Advice matches what actually happened. Seeing a message, entering a password, paying, installing software or allowing remote access each need different steps.
Updates and corrections
We update articles when a site, price, policy or scheme changes, or when new evidence comes to light.
If you spot an error, send us a correction request. Choose “Article correction or content review” and include:
- the article URL
- the specific claim you believe is wrong
- any evidence that supports the correction
We check your report against our evidence. If we got something wrong, we fix it, and when practical we note what changed and why.
Run a business named in an article? See our content review process. We correct or remove claims that don’t hold up, but not accurate reporting of deceptive practices.
Affiliate links and independence
MalwareTips is free to read. Advertising and affiliate links pay for the site.
Some links to security products, including Malwarebytes and AdGuard, are affiliate links. If you buy through one, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.
Commissions don’t decide what we recommend. We suggest security software only when it fits your situation, such as after clicking a risky link, installing unknown software or allowing browser notifications.
When a free scan is enough, we say so. Our guides keep free options in place and make clear which features need a paid version.
We don’t accept payment to call a site a scam, change a conclusion or remove accurate reporting. Read our full affiliate disclosure.
Safety rules for removal guides
A removal guide should fix the problem without creating a new one. We write and update our guides under these rules:
- The steps match your device and the threat. A browser notification problem isn’t treated as a trojan, and a Windows tool isn’t offered for an iPhone.
- We warn you before any step that removes settings, apps or data, and we recommend a backup first.
- No blind registry edits, no deleting system files, and no switching off your security protection to make a step work.
- No unnecessary factory resets or reinstalls. A drastic step appears only when the situation calls for it, with a clear warning.
- We never ask you to download a malware sample or type a password into a cleanup tool.
- On Android, we don’t tell you to switch off legitimate device-management or accessibility services across the board.
- On a work or school device, contact your IT team before following consumer instructions.
- When we write or update a guide, we check software steps against the vendor’s current instructions.
A clean scan is good news, but not a guarantee. Removing malware doesn’t reverse a payment, sign out stolen sessions or make an exposed password safe again.
Ransomware guides
Ransomware guides keep three parts separate: containing the infection and preserving evidence, removing the malware, and recovering your files.
Removing ransomware doesn’t decrypt your files. We never promise decryption, and buying antivirus software is not a decryption key.
For recovery, we explain backups, surviving file versions and genuine decryptors where one exists. Always test recovery on copies of your files first.
If a guide doesn’t solve your problem, volunteers can help for free in our malware removal forum.
Privacy of the reports you send us
Reports sent through our Report a Scam form go to our review team. Nothing is published automatically.
Your email address and original evidence stay private. An edited version of your story appears in Community Scam Reports only if you give separate permission.
Even then, we leave out contact details, faces, signatures, home addresses and full unedited messages.
Sending a report doesn’t guarantee an investigation, an article or the recovery of lost money.
How we use AI tools
Some articles are drafted with help from AI writing tools. A draft is only a starting point. It goes through the same evidence checks and review as any other article.
AI tools never supply the evidence. Facts come from the claim ledger, and every quote, test result and screenshot must be real.
When we can’t capture an original page, an article may use up to two generated illustrations. They illustrate what such a page looks like and are never used as evidence.
The writer named on the article reviews any AI-assisted draft against the collected evidence and is responsible for what is published.
Who is responsible
Our writers are listed on the About page. Questions about this policy can be sent through our contact page.
Questions about this policy? Use our contact form or email contact@malwaretips.com.