Bit Defender, KIS, ESET, AVG, Gdata: not surprising, they deserve their good reputation.
Bullguard: i never used it, but it is quite positive.
Trend Micro: not surprising that he failed, it has a very good web filter but the rest is average.
Avast & Panda : very surprising that they failed, but we knows that Avast without its RT module active, its BB is useless. For Panda i expected better.