Technology AOSP isn't dead, but Google just landed a huge blow to custom ROM developers

[Gandalf_The_Grey]

Content source

https://www.androidauthority.com/google-not-killing-aosp-3566882/

Earlier this year, Google announced it would develop the Android OS fully in private to simplify its development process. By focusing its efforts on a single internal branch, Google aimed to streamline work that was previously split. The news initially spooked some in the Android development community, but the controversy quickly subsided. The impact was minimal, as Google was already developing most of Android behind closed doors and promised that source code releases would continue. Now, however, a recent omission from Google has rekindled fears that the company might stop sharing source code for new Android releases. Google has stated these concerns are unfounded, but other new changes make it harder for the custom ROM community to thrive on Pixel devices.

As promised, Google published the source code for Android 16 this week, allowing independent developers to compile their own builds of the new operating system. This source code was uploaded to the Android Open Source Project (AOSP), as usual, under the permissive Apache 2.0 license.
However, multiple developers quickly noticed a glaring omission from the Android 16 source code release: the device trees for Pixel devices were missing. Google also failed to upload new driver binaries for each Pixel device and released the kernel source code with a squashed commit history. Since Google has shared the device trees, driver binaries, and full kernel source code commit history for years, its omission in this week’s release was concerning.
These omissions led some to speculate this week that Google was taking the first step in a plan to discontinue AOSP. In response, Google’s VP and GM of Android Platform, Seang Chau, refuted these claims. He addressed the speculation in a post on X, stating that “AOSP is NOT going away.”

The more significant issue, however, is the impact this decision will have on developers who build custom ROMs — the community term for hobbyist forks of AOSP. Nolen Johnson, a long-time contributor and reviewer for the LineageOS project, says the process of building these ROMs for Pixel phones will become “painful” moving forward.
Previously, Google made it simple for developers to build AOSP for Pixel devices, but that support is now gone. Developers simply had to “pull the configurations [that] Google created,” add their customizations, and then build. Now, however, they will need to take the old device trees that Google released for Android 15 and “blindly guess and reverse engineer from the prebuilt [binaries] what changes are needed each month.”
This is because making a full Android build for a device — not just a GSI — requires a device tree. This is a “collection of configuration files that define the hardware layout, peripherals, proprietary file listings, and other details for a specific device, allowing the build system to build a proper image for that device.” While Google previously handled this work, developers must now create their own device trees without access to the necessary proprietary source code.

Google’s decision to now discontinue the Pixel as an AOSP reference device is unfortunate, as it has pulled the rug from under developers like the teams at LineageOS and GrapheneOS who build Android for Pixel devices. These developers will still be able to build AOSP for Pixel devices, but it will now be more difficult and painful to do so than before, as they will need to build their own device trees from scratch. This also brings Pixels down to the same level as other Android devices, as developers have long had to build their own device trees, pull binaries, and deal with squashed kernel source code commit history on other devices.

AOSP isn't dead, but Google just landed a huge blow to custom ROM developers

Google has confirmed it isn't discontinuing AOSP, but it's making a change that makes it harder for devs to build Android for Pixel phones.

www.androidauthority.com