App Review [Battle Test] Round 3 - 5 Antivirus vs Ransomware (Manzaitest)

[Manzai]

All antivirus has blocked 2 Ransomware (winlock.exe is missed by all)

Win : Nothing
Eliminate : Gdata, McAfee, Vipre, Crystal, Avira

Crystal Security miss ALL sample !

Tag : @Malware Test , @Kardo Kristal , @xxtoss23 , @MikeV , @omidomi

 

[natan martins]

avira the best among these

 

[Dubseven]

Avira... i expected more than that from Avira...

Thanks for the review.

 

[MikeV]

Great test once more manzai!!!!!!!!
To be honest i didn't expect Crystal Security to miss all samples.......
Emsisoft proves to be better at blocking Ransomware than G Data.....
So... 360, Comodo, Emsisoft,Tiranium are still leading this battle against the beast....

 

[Manzai]

Great test once more manzai!!!!!!!!

So... 360, Comodo, Emsisoft,Tiranium are still leading this battle against the beast....

Win (1 and 2 ) => 360, Comodo, Emsisoft, Tiranium, Norton, Bitdefender

 

[Dubseven]

Great test once more manzai!!!!!!!!
To be honest i didn't expect Crystal Security to miss all samples.......
Emsisoft proves to be better at blocking Ransomware than G Data.....
So... 360, Comodo, Emsisoft,Tiranium are still leading this battle against the beast....

Look like VirusTotal is bad?
Crystal Security is still on startup like Xvirus, they need to have more database entries before attacking battles with big companies like Avira, BitDefender etc.
Emsisoft was always the best on detection, it's my favorite with Avira ^^
G-Data is more better on trojans as i know. In this battle, it's very bad placed.

 

[MikeV]

Emsisoft was always the best on detection, it's my favorite with Avira ^^

Exactly.....Emsisoft WAS the best on detection......now it's 360, and Eset

 

[nsm0220]

Exactly.....Emsisoft WAS the best on detection......now it's 360, and Eset

ESET's zero day protection is not good at all...

Look like VirusTotal is bad?
Crystal Security is still on startup like Xvirus, they need to have more database entries before attacking battles with big companies like Avira, BitDefender etc.
Emsisoft was always the best on detection, it's my favorite with Avira ^^
G-Data is more better on trojans as i know. In this battle, it's very bad placed.

i can tell you why BBs are having a hard time with this they change it so it don't give zero day protection time to read the malware you see in video

 

[Kardo Kristal]

@Manzai Thank you for the test.
Hmm... really interesting. From my video you can see that Crystal Security detects launched processes but it seems that it missed all launched processes in your test and I really currently don't know the issue. I'll create a developer version of Crystal Security ASAP and I hope that you can help me with some feedback. Really bad to see that it missed everything...

Regards,
Kardo

 

[MisterToto]

So there is no jealous! They all loose! But you can see that they detect the first except Crystal, Vipre has improved itself! Don't forget that even if they missed one they're not bad by the way! For example, Comodo detects all malware in the battle but has less detection capacity than Avira or G Data in general. You can't judge with one file. However, good job Manzaï keep going tough through reviews!

 

[nsm0220]

So there is no jealous! They all loose! But you can see that they detect the first except Crystal, Vipre has improved itself! Don't forget that even if they missed one they're not bad by the way! For example, Comodo detects all malware in the battle but has less detection capacity than Avira or G Data in general. You can't judge with one file. However, good job Manzaï keep going tough through reviews!

however that type of ransomware can bypass Comodo,Emsisoft,F-Secure and Qihoo and a few others if they don't update their zero day protection

 

[LAGUN]

@Manzai add XVIRUS in next round plz

 

[omidomi]

@Manzai add OutPost Security Suit Pro.
thanks for nice video.

 

[MisterToto]

@Manzai add OutPost Security Suit Pro.
thanks for nice video.

I totally agree !

 

[Kardo Kristal]

Look like VirusTotal is bad?
Crystal Security is still on startup like Xvirus, they need to have more database entries before attacking battles with big companies like Avira, BitDefender etc.
Emsisoft was always the best on detection, it's my favorite with Avira ^^
G-Data is more better on trojans as i know. In this battle, it's very bad placed.

VirusTotal or any other service is not bad. I'll look into it. I'll do everything to figure out the source of the problem.
BTW: @Dubseven Why avoid the question in this thread (question by @MisterToto)??

Regards,
Kardo

 

[tonibalas]

Manzai great review as always and i"m really looking forward for the next one.I thought that gdata would stop the second one with it's behavior blocker but anyway i think it is a very good product and among the first who used BB analysis and they will continue to grow as time passes buy

 

[Deleted member 21043]

I was expecting the results to come out with how they did, with the exception of McAfee. I had no idea if they would miss all samples, detect them all or detect some/none. @Dubseven Avira is one of the best for detection in my opinion, too.

 

[nsm0220]

Manzai great review as always and i"m really looking forward for the next one.I thought that gdata would stop the second one with it's behavior blocker but anyway i think it is a very good product and among the first who used BB analysis and they will continue to grow as time passes buy

i didn't know that gdata was the 1st to use BB analysis and a lot of BB are having troubles with the restart ransomware

 

[tonibalas]

nsm0220 i"m not sure that g data was the first company to use BB analysis but as i remember it was among the first ones.on the last few years i"m seeing other companies going to that direction and to my understanding BB analysis is a very good method(defence system) to stop 0-day malware

 

[nsm0220]

nsm0220 i"m not sure that g data was the first company to use BB analysis but as i remember it was among the first ones.on the last few years i"m seeing other companies going to that direction and to my understanding BB analysis is a very good method(defence system) to stop 0-day malware

but that restart ransomware is giving BB a hard time