Combining real time protection software with main AV

Would you combine other real time "anti-malware" products with your main AV (free/paid)?


  • Total voters
    39
H

hjlbx

  • Instead of adding a second AV, it is better to add light virtualization, snapshot, anti-executable, or application control (SRP) software; this combo is much, much better physical system protection
  • You can combine 3rd-party AVs together, but no longer with Windows Defender after W10 AU
  • Multiple AVs consume too many system resources - unless one is Webroot and the other another cloud-based AV
 
Last edited by a moderator:

LASER_oneXM

Level 37
Verified
Top Poster
Well-known
Feb 4, 2016
2,520
My combination is

MAIN AV:
F-Secure Internet security 2016 ( real time protection is ON)

OTHER SCANNERS:
Zemana Anti Malware, Malwarebytes Anti Malware (real time potection is OFF)

Zemana and Malwarebyte have both a real-time protection but i turned it OFF: I'm using both as on-demand scanners only. I was not sure if the real-time protection could cause issues with my main AV. My question is: is it safe to turn on the real time protection of Zemana and Malwarebytes ?
 
Last edited:

Logethica

Level 13
Verified
Top Poster
Well-known
Jun 24, 2016
636
I voted:
Yes, if they say it's compatible with other security products..
I run Avast Free Antivirus (Drip-Fed Signature Definitions)....and Crystal Security (Cloud-Based)

IMO..I wouldn't say that running a "companion" AV or AM Increases protection by default,as it depends on the specific two products that one is considering pairing up..
It would be pointless to run both Bitdefender Antivirus & IObit Malware Fighter together as the latter uses the former's engine..


I would personally only use Crystal Security as a companion to a main AV.
 

Darlene

Level 3
Thread author
Verified
Well-known
Aug 14, 2015
113

My combination is

MAIN AV:
F-Secure Internet security 2016 ( real time protection is ON)

OTHER SCANNERS:
Zemana Anti Malware, Malwarebytes Anti Malware (real time potection is OFF)

Zemana and Malwarebyte have both a real-time protection but i turned it OFF: I'm using both as on-demand scanners only. I was not sure if the real-time protection could cause issues with my main AV. My question is: is it safe to turn on the real time protection of Zemana and Malwarebytes ?

I would recommend to leave the real time protection for both zemana and malwarebytes off.
 

Aura

Level 20
Verified
Jul 29, 2014
966
My combination is

MAIN AV:
F-Secure Internet security 2016 ( real time protection is ON)

OTHER SCANNERS:
Zemana Anti Malware, Malwarebytes Anti Malware (real time potection is OFF)

Zemana and Malwarebyte have both a real-time protection but i turned it OFF: I'm using both as on-demand scanners only. I was not sure if the real-time protection could cause issues with my main AV. My question is: is it safe to turn on the real time protection of Zemana and Malwarebytes ?

Missed that post. Unless you actually experience issues and/or FP, there's no reason for you to leave Zemana's and Malwarebytes' real-time protection disabled with your current Antivirus.

If you don't use the main features of the products you bought, why did you buy them instead of using the free version?
 

FrankS

Level 3
Verified
Well-known
Dec 22, 2015
148
I wouldn't use two anti-malware programs with activated realtime-protection at same time/on same system!
One Anti-Malware with a good signature -and cloud-detection is more than enough in relation to anti-virus realtime-protection.
In addition it would be more efficient to use an anti-exploit, sandbox, anti-executable program.
For example my Realtime-Protection-Setup:
Kaspersky Anti-Virus for realtime-scanning with Anti-Exploit/Behavior analysis against malware.
HitmanPro.Alert with Behavior analysis/Exploit-Protection, Keylogger-Protection, Safe-Browsing, Bad USB (and and and...)
VoodooShield Pro (or Premium?) which prevents principle every file to run! You need to accept manually and it shows a virustotal analysis.
 

Darlene

Level 3
Thread author
Verified
Well-known
Aug 14, 2015
113
HitmanPro.Alert isn't an AntiMalware, but I am against running software like MBAM Premium, SAS Pro and other Anti-Malware, even if stated as compatible.
HitmanPro.Alert is quite unique indeed. It is much more than just "anti-exploit" protection. Is it supposed to be a complete replacement for the traditional AV?
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Logethica

FrankS

Level 3
Verified
Well-known
Dec 22, 2015
148
HitmanPro.Alert is quite unique indeed. It is much more than just "anti-exploit" protection. Is it supposed to be a replacement for the traditional AV?
I don't think so. Signature -and Cloud-Based realtime-scanning for malware is also required for a good security-config.
HitmanPro.Alert protects "only" behavior based. I see it more as addition to your anti-malware.
 

Darlene

Level 3
Thread author
Verified
Well-known
Aug 14, 2015
113
Yes indeed. For full compatibility without any rests of risks, it would be recommended to disable the behavior modules of your anti-virus, if existing. I'm gonna do a video, how Kaspersky works with HitmanPro.Alert on Attack.
Looking forward to it. :)
 
  • Like
Reactions: Logethica

DardiM

Level 26
Verified
Honorary Member
Top Poster
Malware Hunter
Well-known
May 14, 2016
1,597
I use with good settings :

In real-time - Normal environement:
Kaspersky Total Security
+ ZAM Premium
+ VS Pro

In real-time - Test environnement (I 'am often under this environnement):
- Shadow Defender
- Crystal Security
+ others tools with others settings

I've got a 6 Cores/ 12 Threads processor, a lot of ram, and 2 x PCI-Express SSD, so I think in this case I can give My PC some works to do
 
Last edited:

LASER_oneXM

Level 37
Verified
Top Poster
Well-known
Feb 4, 2016
2,520
Missed that post. Unless you actually experience issues and/or FP, there's no reason for you to leave Zemana's and Malwarebytes' real-time protection disabled with your current Antivirus.

If you don't use the main features of the products you bought, why did you buy them instead of using the free version?

I have a free full version key from ZEMANA (promotion) but it expires in few days. At this time i'm using only the free version of "Malwarebytes Anti malware": the real time protection is not available in this version. But i wanted to buy both full version keys soon. The reason for my question is: i'm not an expert but maybe it is better to have/use the real time protection to increase the security of my systems. Real time scanner are removing/detecting malware immediately. If you are using only an on demand scanner ( one or two times a week) then maybe it's too late in some cases (and malware can spread.....). This "delay" makes me a little bit "nervous".... ;)
 
Last edited:

shmu26

Level 85
Verified
Honorary Member
Top Poster
Content Creator
Well-known
Jul 3, 2015
8,153
My combination is

MAIN AV:
F-Secure Internet security 2016 ( real time protection is ON)

OTHER SCANNERS:
Zemana Anti Malware, Malwarebytes Anti Malware (real time potection is OFF)

Zemana and Malwarebyte have both a real-time protection but i turned it OFF: I'm using both as on-demand scanners only. I was not sure if the real-time protection could cause issues with my main AV. My question is: is it safe to turn on the real time protection of Zemana and Malwarebytes ?
you are right that it is generally not good to run two AVs at the same time.
But "Anti-Malware"s are a different breed. They are specifically designed to be companion software, and cannot replace a standard AV. Most will work fine with most AVs.
 

About us

  • MalwareTips is a community-driven platform providing the latest information and resources on malware and cyber threats. Our team of experienced professionals and passionate volunteers work to keep the internet safe and secure. We provide accurate, up-to-date information and strive to build a strong and supportive community dedicated to cybersecurity.

User Menu

Follow us

Follow us on Facebook or Twitter to know first about the latest cybersecurity incidents and malware threats.

Top