Should You Remove Carrier IQ From Your Phone?
There's been a lot of paranoia and FUD surrounding a small, IDC-award winning software company called Carrier IQ, ever since a young security researcher named Trevor Eckhart posted video footage showing how some popular phones use Carrier IQ to collect data on your phone.
Officially, as our sister site Geek.com noted in an excellent explainer piece, Carrier IQ makes software that lets customers track when, where, and how you're using your cell phone, all for the purpose of troubleshooting. As Carrier IQ vice president of marketing, Andrew Coward, told me a couple weeks ago, this diagnostic information makes troubleshooting calls go by a lot faster. The activity log sent from Carrier IQ to your cell phone company is pulled every time you call your operator to report a problem, like dropped calls or random outages.
Sounds innocent enough, but the lack of transparency over this firmware has infuriated many owners, so as requested by many readers, we've shown you how to detect and remove Carrier IQ from your device. But before you do, you should know how it will really affect your cell phone service.
Why You Shouldn't
Independent security researcher Dan Rosenberg has analyzed every bit of diagnostic information Carrier IQ collects, and why, and concluded that Carrier IQ actually performs some useful tasks.
"Based on my research, CarrierIQ implements a potentially valuable service designed to help improve user experience on cellular networks," he wrote in a blog post.
In his meticulous analysis of a Samsung Epic 4G on Sprint, Rosenberg found no malicious, privacy-violating use of Carrier IQ software; it cannot record text messages, keystrokes, phone calls, Web page contents or emails, he said.
However he acknowledged that the software could be altered in the future to "perform nefarious actions."
Similarly Alexandru Balan, a senior product manager at BitDefender, said, "if the application is only used to improve the user experience, it's entirely anonymous and no sensitive information is used to track individuals, you could say that the Carrier IQ user base serves a common good and helps breed improvements."
Neither Sprint, T-Mobile, or AT&T were available to comment at press time, but all have denied privacy violations in their use of Carrier IQ.
An internal document leaked to T-Mo News (good timing, huh?) said T-Mobile uses Carrier IQ for three purposes: to diagnose battery performance anxiety, dropped calls, and application failures.
Read more >>