Scam report Scam Alerts

An Art Commission Came With a Digital Check and a Request for Money Back

By Lapain Epuran10 min read

A stranger wants to commission your art. They’re willing to pay before you start, and they say they can email you a check.

When the check comes through, the client has one more request. They say you need to send back part of what they paid.

American Bankers Association consumer guide to fake checks and overpayments

Overview

The buyer used a real commission as the reason to send a check

A US artist said a prospective client wanted to pay for a commission with a digital check. The client said they were in Europe and did not have PayPal.

The client asked for the artist’s name, email address and bank name. The artist supplied those details and received a check by email.

Afterward the client claimed they had sent too much and asked the artist to return the difference. The artist blocked the accounts and deleted the message without depositing anything.

The request to return money is the central risk

A check and a refund sent through an app are separate transactions. If a bank rejects the check later, the money the artist sends back can still be gone.

The FTC’s fake-check guidance explains why a bank can make money available before it discovers that a check is invalid or unauthorized.

Use the original commission terms to keep the situation clear:

  • The price you actually quoted and the payment method you agreed to accept.
  • Whether the client emailed a check, sent a payment request or provided only a screenshot.
  • Whether you deposited anything and the amount shown in your own account.
  • How much the client asked you to return, to whom and through which service.
  • Whether any payment actually left your account.

The artist walked away before a deposit or loss

The artist reported no download, deposit or refund. The bank never evaluated the particular check, so its validity was not determined.

The false-overpayment pattern is documented by the FTC. The article’s warning applies to sending your own money in response to the buyer’s claim, regardless of the payment file’s appearance.

If you share only a name, an email address and the name of your bank, the response differs from a case involving account numbers, credentials or a completed transfer.

How the Art Commission Overpayment Scam Works

Step 1: A plausible customer asks you to take a different payment method

The request sounds plausible when it first comes up. The client wants your work and says your regular payment service isn’t available where they live.

Ask the client to agree to a payment method you already know how to use. You can keep the commission open while they decide whether that works.

Read the storefront or invoicing service’s own terms to see whether it requires you to keep the conversation or payment on the platform where contact began.

An artist can decline a payment method without giving a stranger the name of their bank. State your available options and ask whether the client can use one.

Step 2: A check shows up by email

The buyer may call the attachment a digital check or say it can be deposited from a phone. Contact your bank before attempting to deposit an unfamiliar emailed item.

The check may display the expected recipient or impressive-looking payment details. Those details cannot show that the person sending it has authority to use that account.

The artist left the attachment unopened and never made a deposit. The buyer’s request to send back part of the check was enough to put the job on hold.

If you still have the email, preserve it without opening an unknown attachment. Your bank can tell you how it wants you to share information about a suspected check.

Step 3: The client asks for part of the money back

The artist said the client claimed the check was for too much. The buyer then turned that claim into a request for the artist to pay them.

A genuine client can discuss canceling an incorrect transaction and making a fresh one. Talk to your bank or payment service about any correction before sending a refund.

If the buyer asks you to forward the difference to a third party, stop. The original commission price should have no connection to an unfamiliar recipient.

The exact amount of the check in this case was unclear. The decision would stay the same with a small overpayment because your own refund is still a separate transfer.

Step 4: The money you sent can outlast the deposit

If a bank makes money available from a check, its app may let you spend it. That display alone cannot settle whether the bank will return the item later.

A return can reverse the deposit even after you send a separate payment. Get the bank’s advice before spending any of the provisional credit.

The artist in this case stopped before depositing the check. If you stopped there too, save the payment request and check what personal information you already shared.

If you already refunded money, call the service you used to pay. Report that transfer while you also tell your bank about the emailed check.

How to Handle a Check That Comes With a Refund Demand

Put the price and payment terms in writing

Send a written quote with a defined price and what it includes. An itemized estimate gives both sides a clear reference if the client claims a different amount.

When you take an advance, say what it covers. Keep the initial receipt and later payments against the same project so you can tell when something does not belong.

If the client has a different invoice number or amount, ask them to confirm it in writing. There is no need to process a transfer while that question is open.

If someone introduces a second person to pay on their behalf, verify the connection under your own payment rules. You can decline a transaction you cannot match to the commission.

Find out what an available deposit actually means

Ask the deposit team what status it can confirm and whether it has checked the item. Tell it that the sender asked for an overpayment refund.

A balance can show funds before the bank discovers a problem with the check. Ask a bank employee what the displayed amount means for your deposit.

Ask whether the bank wants you to leave the funds untouched while it reviews the item. Keep the original date, deposit reference and any message about availability.

If you used a business account, tell anyone authorized to spend from it to leave the funds alone until the bank answers. That avoids accidental use of a disputed credit.

If the client already has some of your information

Start with the information the buyer received. A name and email allow further contact, while a password, code or bank account number calls for a separate response.

If the next email appears to be from your bank, use the app or your card to check it. The client already knows which bank name would sound plausible.

If you gave away your email password, secure that account promptly. Review recent sign-ins and keep unfamiliar messages that could be related to the commission.

If you deleted the email, your mail provider may still have it in Trash. You can retrieve its subject, date and sender for the report without clicking its links.

Put the artwork on hold during a payment dispute

Set aside the commission file and keep any written agreement. Do not send the final artwork while you are trying to resolve a suspicious payment.

If you started sketching before the check arrived, record the time and what the client approved. Your financial loss, if any, depends on actual transfers and bank activity.

An email saying the client will sue or file a complaint can arrive after you refuse to pay. Preserve it without accepting the accompanying payment demand.

If you use a legitimate commission marketplace, tell support what happened before closing the project. It may be able to retain the thread, and you can ask about cancellation there.

Give a genuine client a way to fix an overpayment

Give them the original invoice amount and let them correct the payment through the provider they used. An honest explanation does not require you to rush a separate transfer.

If your bank says it has no item matching the buyer’s claim, document that answer. You can ask the buyer to confirm the receipt on their side without sending money.

If the buyer offers a new check before the first is resolved, call the bank before accepting it. Otherwise you could be reporting two items with the same supposed purpose.

Keep the overpayment discussion together with the quote. A third party reviewing it can see the amount originally agreed and the point when the client asked for money back.

Check whether the alleged refund ever left your account

Open your payment service directly and look for an outgoing transaction. If no payment occurred, save the notice as a claim and report the message through the service.

If the notice gives a different recipient from the one in your app, give support the app record. A second demand cannot change which payment your bank actually sent.

If the client says the bank has called them to confirm the transfer, call your bank yourself. Ask about the deposit and any money that already moved on your account.

Start the next commission with a fresh invoice and your regular payment terms. The suspicious buyer doesn’t need a new channel for contacting you.

For a platform payment, leave a record of the skipped refund and why you contacted support. Preserve the payout or transaction history even if the buyer closes their account.

The American Bankers Association’s fake-check guide describes the overpayment pattern and the risk of transferring the supposed excess before the original payment is verified.

If the client presses for a same-day answer, send your standard payment terms once. You can put the project on hold without discussing your bank or daily transfer limit.

If a third party claims it paid, ask for the original client name and invoice number. Keep the payee unchanged while you verify it.

What to Do if You Have Fallen Victim to This Scam

  1. Hold off on sending money back and save your quote, the client’s message and the payment instructions. Leave new demands unanswered while you check your account.

  2. Call the bank that took the deposit and explain that the check came by email and the sender asked for money back. Keep the original deposit reference handy.

  3. Report any money you sent back to the company that processed the transfer. Give it the recipient, amount and timestamp so it can explain the available recovery options.

  4. Tell the relevant provider if you shared an account number, card details or a code. Change any password you entered through a link the buyer sent you.

  5. Report the buyer’s account on the platform where the commission started. In the US, you can also send the details of the overpayment request to FTC ReportFraud.

  6. Ask for separate case numbers for the check deposit and any transfer you made. Use the official app or phone number to check each case for updates.

The FTC’s warning about fake checks on social media describes how supposed clients use a social connection or creative opportunity to steer people into a payment.

If the client never got a payment or a deposit from you, tell the platform it was an attempt. Preserve the actual overpayment request if it is still available.

If a payment processor follows up, use its official channel to confirm where to send evidence. A new contact offering to recover your payment can be another impersonator.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does an emailed check always mean fraud?

Ask your bank about the specific item and its accepted deposit methods. A message asking you to pay back part of an unfamiliar check is reason to stop.

Can I send back the difference after the balance goes up?

Ask the bank about the item’s actual status. A visible balance can include funds the bank later reverses, while your refund is a separate payment.

Is the bank name enough for somebody to access my account?

A bank name alone is not a credential. Protect yourself against new messages using that name and contact the bank if you gave away anything more sensitive.

Should I open the attachment to prove it is fake?

Do not open an unknown file for that purpose. Save the message details and ask the bank or platform how to report it using what you already have.

What if I never deposited it or sent money?

You can report the attempted payment scheme, block the contact and look out for follow-ups. If you sent credentials or financial details, secure those separately.

What should a legitimate client do if they actually overpaid?

Use the original payment provider’s process or agree on a clean replacement payment. Confirm the status independently before giving the client money from your own account.

The Bottom Line

Decline an art commission payment that comes with an emailed check and a demand to send money back. Keep to the price and payment terms you agreed on.

If you deposited it or sent a refund, call the bank and the provider that handled the outgoing money. Give each one the transaction it can investigate.

Make your next click a safer one.

Spotting a scam is a good start. These tools can add protection when you browse, open messages, or download software.

Affiliate links We may earn a commission if you buy through these links, at no extra cost to you. How we’re funded

MalwarebytesSCAM & MALWARE PROTECTION

Scam awareness. Malware protection.

Malwarebytes combines device protection with tools for checking suspicious messages and links, so you have more information before you act.

  • Scam Guard for suspicious messages
  • Real-time malware protection with Premium
Explore MalwarebytesExplore features on the official website
AdGuardAD & TRACKER BLOCKING

Less clutter. More control.

AdGuard filters intrusive ads and trackers, helping reduce unwanted interruptions and giving you more control over your browsing.

  • Blocks intrusive ads and pop-ups
  • Filters trackers while you browse
Explore AdGuardExplore features on the official website

Features vary by device and plan. These tools add protection; they do not guarantee that a website or offer is trustworthy.

Join the discussion

0 comments

Share your experience or ask a question about this article.

Discussion

Start the conversation

Have a question or something useful to share? Add the first comment.

Report a comment

Reports are private and reviewed by a moderator.

Written by

Lapain Epuran

Lapain Epuran investigates product scams, from supplements sold with miracle-cure claims to gadgets pushed through misleading ads. She has more than 10 years of experience in investigations and checks each product's claims, seller and refund terms before giving a verdict.

4,518 articlesWriting since 2024
More from Lapain →

MalwareTips community · since 2010

Stuck on a step? 75,000+ members can help you for free.

Post your question on the forum and our volunteer malware removal experts will walk you through it, step by step.

75K+members
999K+forum messages
100K+forum topics
17+years online

Previous

The Rental Tour Looked Real, but the Lease Kept Naming a Different Address

Next

A Fake Handyman Took a Zelle Payment. The Real Business Never Booked It

Share