Well, to start with I just like the GUI better in Avast One. I will admit though that it has taken me a very long time to be able to say and believe that. When Avast One was first introduced I did not like the GUI at all, I thought it was too cartoonish and cluttered. But I am OK with it now. I think Avast One is the better choice because not only does it have very strong AV protection, but there are also privacy and security tools that I can actually use. The VPN for one, I have never been a big fan of VPN's but I may start using the free one in Avast for online banking and bill payments. With all the criminal stuff happening online now I really feel like I can't be too careful. There are other good tools in Avast too, it can help identify problems with passwords, software that needs to be updated, it has good privacy and security tip info, and it can clear browing history in one click. I also like how Avast now has a setting where you can turn off the upsell nag notifications.
For my use, Avast One just seems to be a more modern, complete and advanced version of Avast Free Antivirus. I know the AV test site reviews need to be taken with a healthy grain of salt, but Avast and AVG consistently get good scores and reviews. I read good things about Avast here on MWT lately as well. Plus I was already using the free Avast One AV on my Pixel 6 phone, so I had a pretty good idea how it would work on my laptop. Avast One is the only free cell phone AV I have ever found that actually runs in real time and works a lot like a computer AV. I have never had any trouble at all with Avast One Essential on my phone.
I also think that Gen Digital must surely have the staff, technical ability and financial backing to address any problems that might come up so they can keep Avast updated and effective. Here is a link to just one of the sites that helped me in my decision, it's from 2023 and details Avast One Essential but the info still applies to Avast One Basic and Avast Free AV:
What is Avast One? Avast One vs free antivirus. Essential vs Premium version. Comparison, Download, Review, Features, Discounts.
www.techsupportall.com
C.H.