Paul.R

Level 17
Verified

F‑Secure SAFE is an award-winning internet security suite that won the AV‑TEST Best Protection award 2018. SAFE protects you from viruses, trojans and ransomware. SAFE also secures your online banking connection. You can set limits for internet usage for children. You and your family can surf safely — both on desktop and mobile.


 

MacDefender

Level 12
Verified
Interesting test.... Just some observations:

  • Web protection seemed to miss 2 phishing pages. Perhaps the weakness here is specific to phishing?
  • Seems like one of the malicious links downloads a VBS and that is then caught by DeepGuard, of all things!
  • F-Secure static scanning, unsurprisingly, seems to have let some samples escape but caught them dynamically when they were run (not even by DeepGuard for a few of them). This seems to match our observations that F-Secure isn't the best at static scanning even though its overall protection is quite good. If you rely on static scanning as a primary means, it's better to choose something else.
  • I was surprised that running all 23 missed samples resulted in no infections. In terms of testing methodology, not sure I would have run all the malware simultaneously -- depending on how these samples attempt to infect, running them all concurrently could've affected their ability to infect the system.
  • Zemana seems to have identified 7-zip.dll as malicious. Seems like a false alarm to me.

Though there were no misses here, as far as F-Secure is concerned, it's worth mentioning that their BB, DeepGuard, is allegedly sensitive to how the files are introduced onto the system. In this case, the sample pack was extracted with F-Secure turned off completely. It's usually recommended to introduce the files via removable drive or network download, both of which cause DeepGuard to err on the side of suspicion. However, it seems like in the past 1-2 years, DeepGuard cares less about this (perhaps because this behavior made testing F-Secure difficult)
 

upnorth

Moderator
Verified
Staff member
Malware Hunter
The version in this video is 17.7 and was tested 2 months ago. F-Secure SAFE is since June 11th updated to version 17.8. Personal I'm more interested in tests on that and extra so as that update was a major one.

About it's scan capabilities, I personal can't and wouldn't final judge any vendor from one single test. This video shows the static scan got a 97,4 % detection rate/score. IMO that's not bad and absolutely not bad enough that one would have to jump on another solution just because of that result alone. I strongly advice people to collect more information before install and test products no matter the company/vendor or brand.

The dynamic tests was terrible performed IMO. Zero/no overview of outbound connections and no autoruns results. Several samples was also obviously not working and that could easy been tested, before. Something called WMaware could very well been a reason. Great that a reboot was finally made, but I have no idea why use a abandonware as SOS ( second opinion scanner ). Even Nortons Power Eraser is a much better choice for several reasons.
 
Last edited: