Software Review Comodo FW bypass malware the sandbox (sandbox hips off + on) and voodooshield (autopilot)

Reviews reflect the reviewer's setup and methods. Check the evidence and limitations.
I know exactly what the argument is going to be -- that it isn't malware. It is the same argument applied to a script I write to delete your entire drive without your consent. Technically, it isn't malware. Really ? I'd bet you'd consider it malware after deleting your entire drive.

Mark my words...
 
As a rule of thumb : it is a bypass when you right-click on the file > run it in the Sandbox and changes are made to real system. (CIS case)

Really ?

I submitted a Zbot sample to COMODO Engineering not long ago that completely disabled COMODO upon execution. All CIS modules were completely disabled, but the GUI was still running.

All you have to do is download a few Virussign malware packs and eventually you will find something that can disable COMODO HIPS and\or sandbox.
 
Really ?

I submitted a Zbot sample to COMODO Engineering not long ago that completely disabled COMODO upon execution. All CIS modules were completely disabled, but the GUI was still running.

All you have to do is download a few Virussign malware packs and eventually you will find something that can disable COMODO HIPS and\or sandbox.

Not sure what to say.. I have submitted bypasses that were fixed. I could post it after version 10 is released.
CIS virtualization is tricky as it provides more compatibility. If you have a driver installed then (for compatibility purposes) you could make use of that driver and action will not be virtualized by default. Example: run Process Hacker, exit Process Hacker, virtualize Process Hacker and terminate non-virtualized application. This is possible because you have launched a driver upon first run and virtualized instance makes use of that driver.
 
Last edited:
Not sure what to say.. I have submitted bypasses that were fixed. I could post it after version 10 is released.
CIS virtualization is tricky as it provides more compatibility. If you have a driver installed then (for compatibility purposes) you could make use of that driver and action will not be virtualized by default. Example: run Process Hacker, exit Process Hacker, virtualize Process Hacker and terminate CIS. This is possible because you have launched a driver upon first run and virtualized instance makes use of that driver.

I can find no rhyme nor reason as to what, when, and why COMODO fixes some things and not others.

I submit all the sample directly to Haibo Zhang - Director of COMODO Engineering (Beijing, China).

I worked for months collecting data for the "disappearing rules" bug. It has been submitted repeatedly to everyone - Haibo, Artyom (Ukraine -responsible for the rules module) and BuketB.

But you're right... the COMODO tech did rate Thingthing.exe as Safe - I checked the Safe List. Sure enough, it's rated as Trusted. You were right and I was wrong.

I suppose we can write it off as a mis-rating by the tech.
 
Hi obviously it is a fault whitelist I made another video if you delete a whitelist suppliers system is clean. Comodo killswitch takes a file as safe .Voodooshield succumbs in lock mode, it's weird .- (

To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.
 
FYI verdict changed to malware.
http://i.imgur.com/HK7aHB5.png
Damn, someone with power took action. I am sure experts don't do analysis at a Sunday evening for a random file that already was checked.
As you see someone just changed the verdict. It is still saying "Human Expert Analysis Date: 2016-10-22 22:46:34 ( 8 days ago )"
 
Damn, someone with power took action. I am sure experts don't do analysis at a Sunday evening for a random file that already was checked.
As you see someone just changed the verdict. It is still saying "Human Expert Analysis Date: 2016-10-22 22:46:34 ( 8 days ago )"
It's great to see Comodo guys acted fast on this one!
Great share by the OP and interesting discussion here!

EDIT: Also big thanks to @cruelsister for picking that one up!
At the time I tested that one with a default Internet Security Preset (+HIPS @ Security Preset) configured CIS, sandbox wasn't triggered, pretty sure because of the previous whitelisting.
As for it's actions it changes fonts and immediately restarts the PC. Haven't seen anything more like in the initial video on this one, as by restart my ShadowDefender session ended.
 
Last edited:
That's not what i said. Check the expert analysis date. Now someone changed the verdict because they were informed about this post probably.

Click on "Human Expert Analysis" tab. :)

Human Expert Analysis Results
Analysis Start Date: 2016-10-22 22:32:14 ( 8 days ago )
Analysis End Date: 2016-10-22 22:46:34 ( 8 days ago )
File Upload Date: 2016-10-22 20:25:13 ( 8 days ago )
Update Date: 2016-10-30 17:50:55 ( 26 minutes ago )
Human Expert Analyst Feedback: malware
Verdict: Malware
 

MalwareTips community

Join the discussion

Create a free account to reply to this thread, ask your own questions and get help from the community.

  • Reply and ask questions
  • Get alerts when someone answers
  • Free malware removal help

Join 75,678 members who help each other for free, since 2010.

Create free account
or continue with

Recently browsing

Members and guests who viewed this thread in the last 5 minutes

Back
Top