App Review Comodo's killer.

It is advised to take all reviews with a grain of salt. In extreme cases some reviews use dramatization for entertainment purposes.
Content created by
@Andy Ful
Nikola Milanovic said:
I Kepp cloud based analysis on because i like to Submit samples to Comodo/Xcitium so they rate them :)
for exeample i subbmited this sample yesterday and Comodo/Xcitium rated it as Malicious View attachment 287175
Click to expand...
They do sometimee classify stuff as malicious that isn't malicious and usually when you send it to human analysis they correct it but rarely even human objection will fail and a false positive will stay detected

About improving their signatures they definitely did as I had a sample not detected by eset but was detected inside comodo container by virus scope
But since virus scope does so poorly in tests I wouldn't recommend it as an av replacement but as an added layer
 
  • Like
  • +Reputation
Reactions: roger_m, simmerskool and Andy Ful
Vitali Ortzi said:
They do sometimee classify stuff as malicious that isn't malicious and usually when you send it to human analysis they correct it but rarely even human objection will fail and a false positive will stay detected

About improving their signatures they definitely did as I had a sample not detected by eset but was detected inside comodo container by virus scope
But since virus scope does so poorly in tests I wouldn't recommend it as an av replacement but as an added layer
Click to expand...
in my tests VirusScope does good
 
Nikola Milanovic said:
in my tests VirusScope does good
Click to expand...
Comodo doesn't detect a lot of malware so although it did surprise me once at least in my machine it wasn't great at detection but so far perfect at prevention on my machines
As a comodo fan I would love it to keep improving but do far there was shown certain tricks like dll hijacking can allow malware to bypass the sandbox so at prevention it can technically keep improving although near perfection and as an av virus scope is far below industry standard (I really love how light it is though)
 
  • Like
Reactions: roger_m, simmerskool, rashmi and 2 others
Nikola Milanovic said:
They do detect the malware if u submit it to them
Click to expand...
Not sure that's exactly fair
But since you use prevention and then manual submission and wait till it's clean/ malware
You should be safe against most of the malware in the wild 99.99%+ except a few tactics shown in this fourm
And Andy gave some solution for most of the 0.0001 percentage
 
  • Like
Reactions: simmerskool and Andy Ful
Vitali Ortzi said:
Not sure that's exactly fair
But since you use prevention and then manual submission and wait till it's clean/ malware
You should be safe against most of the malware in the wild 99.99%+ except a few tactics shown in this fourm
Click to expand...
Yeah i installed Xcitium just because i love to submit to them Samples for Analysis so they rate them thats why i am a comodo fan
 
  • Like
Reactions: simmerskool
Nikola Milanovic said:
not only do they rate files quickly but on the Xcitium Client the signatures are much much better then on free Xcitium
Click to expand...
I hope they just find a way to deal with every poc 100%
Once they do its a really good solution for enterprises btw it's actually far cheaper for enterprises over other products at enterprise scale purchase
 
  • Like
Reactions: simmerskool
Actually I'm interested what an mssp thinks about xcitium
I know @Trident didn't like it but wonder what do they believe should be improved for xcitium to be a full solution budget offering and if they think today it can be used as an added defense layer as it's really good at prevention
 
  • Like
Reactions: simmerskool
Vitali Ortzi said:
Actually I'm interested what an mssp thinks about xcitium
I know @Trident didn't like it but wonder what do they believe should be improved for xcitium to be a full solution budget offering and if they think today it can be used as an added defense layer as it's really good at prevention
Click to expand...
Xcitium has much much more users on their business
 
Vitali Ortzi said:
What's their market share ?
Click to expand...
They get 750 Million dollars and even Billion dollars on their enterprise and business products as they are pretty good
1736966814029.png
 
Nikola Milanovic said:
They get 750 Million dollars and even Billion dollars on their enterprise and business products as they are pretty good
Click to expand...
Not too bad it's like 5% when you consider the size of the market wich is 26.50 billion
www.statista.com

Endpoint Security - Worldwide | Statista Market Forecast

Worldwide: Revenue in the Endpoint Security market is projected to reach US$15.41bn in 2025. Definition : Endpoint security solutions or endpoint protection refers to practices designed to protect the various endpoints on a network or in the cloud, such as desktop computers, laptops, network...
www.statista.com www.statista.com
 
  • Like
Reactions: simmerskool and Nikola Milanovic
Vitali Ortzi said:
Not too bad it's like 5% when you consider the size of the market wich is 26.50 billion
www.statista.com

Endpoint Security - Worldwide | Statista Market Forecast

Worldwide: Revenue in the Endpoint Security market is projected to reach US$15.41bn in 2025. Definition : Endpoint security solutions or endpoint protection refers to practices designed to protect the various endpoints on a network or in the cloud, such as desktop computers, laptops, network...
www.statista.com www.statista.com
Click to expand...
So are you ready to switch to Xcitium Client Security 13?
i will help you to switch if you have troubles
 
  • Like
Reactions: simmerskool
Nikola Milanovic said:
So are you ready to switch to Xcitium Client Security 13?
Click to expand...
if I were a business probably not fully
As a consumer it's too expansive for single licenses and is niche as it has too many false positives for many users but some can actually use it like my mom who doesn't install software frequently (using cruel sister comodo and configured defender there )

For myself only as a layer since there are wild malware with dll hijacking that can bypass It
Like the ransomware shown on this fourm

Virus scope is too weak even xcitium version looking at lab tests so you have to use it at default deny and even then it's not good enough for enterprises as there are possible bypasses that targeted malware can use and maybe some wild malware may have some bypass that will work on xcitium too
 
  • Like
Reactions: simmerskool

You may also like...