In such default you will have a very least notification since most of known programs are registered automatically or included as pre-default settings. Highly suggest to conduct a little research and make your preferences of using advance settings'; why not add like manual firewall feature like Glasswire or WFC which design to integrate from built in firewall of Windows.
Microsoft have to improve on usability rather than "Do You Want To Allow This?" Why do you think Windows Defender has become mostly automated in response to malware threats.
If you want to tune Windows Firewall without 3rd party software, use the Advanced Settings, but requires manual configuring.
Install the following program on two networked computers: http://ditto-cp.sourceforge.net/
WAF will give you inbound and outbound notifications and you pick whether it can talk on Home/Private networks and/or Public networks.
They aren't concentrating at all on look and feel--that's users' issue who want convenient prompts rather than creating rules manually. GlassWire provides a really, really nice look and feel and it's a GUI to create WAF rules on-demand.
I don't know what else MS should provide; WAF tells you the program and whether it is listening (server service), sending, or receiving. What else is there?