geohac said:
- Emphasise the need to back up data.
Thanks, I do emphasize this in the second paragraph of the article.
geohac said:
- Replace Emsisoft Emergency Kit with SAS Portable
What is your reasoning for this? I was under the impression that Emsisoft Anti-Malware has a very high detection ratio. Is there a reason I should get rid of Emsisoft?
geohac said:
- Remove CCE. A novice user would have problems using it.
CCE is very important in my article as it lets you make sure the computer is actually clean and also relatively easily make the computer able to be cleaned by many of the other scanners. Also, I know that any FP's it has will not be on Windows files because all of these are in the whitelist and therefore will not be scanned.
Thus I can tell anyone to scan with it knowing that it won't find any really important files dangerous. Also, if their computer is that infected I don't think many people would complain too much that a program they can reinstall no longer works. It's a very powerful tool that if you follow my instructions should be able to get the computer back to working order.
Also, I added the section about
Simplest Methods To Clean Your Computer to hopefully clean the computer without even requiring it. That was the whole point of the first section, it's essentially hoping that the computer's not even infected to the point that CCE is necessary. I don't see a point in removing it from the article.
geohac said:
Also, some of the steps are redundant. You mention TDSSKiller and HitmanPro in mutiple locations.
Thanks for pointing this out. However, this article is meant to be followed from one step to the next (unless you skip the first section, which you are allowed to do). Thus, if I think another scanner could cleaned enough for another to now work then I will advise it again.
The idea I'm following is that I want to be able to get someone's computer running in as little time as possible. If I wanted it to work in as few steps as possible then I'd always tell them to do full scans and scan with everything one after the other. Instead I give them advice which will hopefully allow them to skip all steps after it.
It's a different approach that I really hope will catch on.
Also, thanks for pointing out about the importance of making backups. I realized I hadn't remembered to emphasize it in my article about How to Stay Safe Online, so I made a section for it. It can be found
here.
Thanks, please let me know if you have any further suggestions.