This is not current, but I think it's still useful. It's really good to see that the free ones did well, isn't it?
Results and comments - www.matousec.com
Product Product score Level reached Protection level
Recommendation Report Award
Comodo Internet Security Premium 7.0.317799.4142 FREE
97 % 11+ Excellent
GET IT NOW!
Outpost Security Suite Pro 9.1.4643.690.1951 90 % 11 Excellent
GET IT NOW!
Kaspersky Internet Security 2015 15.0.0.463 89 % 11 Very good
GET IT NOW!
SpyShelter Firewall 9.2 89 % 11 Very good
GET IT NOW!
Privatefirewall 7.0.30.3 FREE 88 % 11 Very good N/A
Outpost Security Suite Free 7.1.1.3431.520.1248 FREE
71 % 11 Good Not recommended
–
VirusBuster Internet Security Suite 4.1 71 % 10 Good Not recommended
–
ESET Smart Security 8.0.304.0 67 % 11 Good Not recommended
–
Jetico Personal Firewall 2.1.0.13.2471 58 % 10 Poor Not recommended
–
ZoneAlarm Extreme Security 2013 11.0.780.000
34 % 6 Very poor Not recommended
–
ZoneAlarm Free Antivirus + Firewall 13.1.211.000 FREE
34 % 6 Very poor Not recommended
See the webpage for many other also-rans