ESET should be enough, you don't need Malwarebytes. You have a firewall and AV covered, add ScriptSafe to your Web browser.
Remove HerdProtect, this is outdated, the author has never updated the software for ages now. This will add a further spot that malicious individuals will target. I would remove this.
Also add Macrium Reflect as your backup solution, going forward with these tips you should be fine.
~LDogg