- Jun 14, 2015
- 857
My last malware was over a decade ago; that question needs more options.
I have never paid for security products; there isn't a need to and I have better things to do with my cash. The argument that retail products have to be better because why would they charge for something that isn't better? is a false assumption.
Tested but didn't make the cut
- Avast free: Intrusive ads, false-positives, slightly declining detection rates and seems to have gotten slower
- Avira free: Ads
- Qihoo 360: Far too many false-positives; otherwise a near-perfect product
- Comodo Internet Security: sub-par AV, buggy, misleading UI and manual, requires more interventions than every *-Addicts-Anonymous member combined
- TinyWall: Is very nice and does a pretty good job and what it's for but outbound firewalls aren't of much use and they certainly aren't worth the constant nagging (which TinyWall is worse as it doens't prompt you; you have to whack-a-mole the traffic list which only goes back 2 minutes)
- Malwarebytes Anti-Exploit:interfered with AV scanning, false positives, redundant and unnecessary as I'm not running Windows XP (seems to be fixed now, not sure what the deal was, trying out free version but still question my need for it)
- Malwarebytes Anti-Malware in real-time: I ran this for about a year and it is pretty much redundant with everything else I have running now and I actually read installation dialog boxes before clicking buttons
- AdBlock: Works well but it is slow
- uBlock/uBlock Origin: My second choice; the broke a site or two
- AdGuard: I saw AdChoice ads!?!?!? (Don't use CCEnhancer Chrome Logs* option)
- Smarty Uninstaller: It didn't detect changes in my test, it doesn't have a shell menu extension, and the interface isn't as nice as Soft Organizer. I would choose it if Soft Organizer weren't available for free at a giveaway (I got both as give-aways)
- Emsisoft Antimalware: It looks nice and--big plus here--is serious about detecting PUPs. I wanted to see if there was a scaled-down free version but I only saw a 30-day trial.
- Multi-Commander: Nice but a bit slow and crashes with some shell extensions; I'm sticking with XYplorer (free)
- Norton DNS "ConnectSafe": I don't have a problem with a reasonable rate of false-positives but I do have a problem with not having an option to continue in spite of the warning.
My quick AV test:
http://malwaretips.com/threads/quick-file-detection-test-qihoo-vs-avast-vs-comodo.47091/
Hardware:
Intel Core i5-2500K @ 4.2GHz at stock voltages
Zalman 9900 cooler (round one, nickel finish with blue lighting)
Gigabyte Z68XP-UD4 motherboard
8GB Mushkin DDR3-2133MHz (2x4GB)
Asus TI-DC2O-2GD5 GTX660Ti GPU
Crucial m4 128GB SSD
Western Digital Black 2TB HDD WD2002FAEX
Seagate Green 2TB 5900RPM (backup drive)
A Couple Of DVD Burners, Lite-ON or something
Enermax Galaxy EVO 1250W power supply
Antec Twelve Hundred case
Dell Professional 27-inch monitor
Dell Professional 24-inch monitor (portrait)
Logitech G19 keyboard
Logitech G13 game-board
Logitech G9x mouse
Logitech F710 Xbox controller
APC BR1500 UPS (I get about 20 mins or so)
Wife has same desktop in an Antec Nine-Hundred Two case, one monitor
Gaming Laptop:
MSI GT70 Dominator 2PC
17.3" display
Intel i7-4800MQ CPU * 8GB DDR3-1600 * Samsung 850 EVO 250GB SSD
GTX 870M GPU
Integrated SteelSeries keyboard
Logitech Anywhere MX wireless mouse
I have never paid for security products; there isn't a need to and I have better things to do with my cash. The argument that retail products have to be better because why would they charge for something that isn't better? is a false assumption.
Tested but didn't make the cut
- Avast free: Intrusive ads, false-positives, slightly declining detection rates and seems to have gotten slower
- Avira free: Ads
- Qihoo 360: Far too many false-positives; otherwise a near-perfect product
- Comodo Internet Security: sub-par AV, buggy, misleading UI and manual, requires more interventions than every *-Addicts-Anonymous member combined
- TinyWall: Is very nice and does a pretty good job and what it's for but outbound firewalls aren't of much use and they certainly aren't worth the constant nagging (which TinyWall is worse as it doens't prompt you; you have to whack-a-mole the traffic list which only goes back 2 minutes)
- Malwarebytes Anti-Exploit:
- Malwarebytes Anti-Malware in real-time: I ran this for about a year and it is pretty much redundant with everything else I have running now and I actually read installation dialog boxes before clicking buttons
- AdBlock: Works well but it is slow
- uBlock/uBlock Origin: My second choice; the broke a site or two
- Smarty Uninstaller: It didn't detect changes in my test, it doesn't have a shell menu extension, and the interface isn't as nice as Soft Organizer. I would choose it if Soft Organizer weren't available for free at a giveaway (I got both as give-aways)
- Emsisoft Antimalware: It looks nice and--big plus here--is serious about detecting PUPs. I wanted to see if there was a scaled-down free version but I only saw a 30-day trial.
- Multi-Commander: Nice but a bit slow and crashes with some shell extensions; I'm sticking with XYplorer (free)
- Norton DNS "ConnectSafe": I don't have a problem with a reasonable rate of false-positives but I do have a problem with not having an option to continue in spite of the warning.
My quick AV test:
http://malwaretips.com/threads/quick-file-detection-test-qihoo-vs-avast-vs-comodo.47091/
Hardware:
Intel Core i5-2500K @ 4.2GHz at stock voltages
Zalman 9900 cooler (round one, nickel finish with blue lighting)
Gigabyte Z68XP-UD4 motherboard
8GB Mushkin DDR3-2133MHz (2x4GB)
Asus TI-DC2O-2GD5 GTX660Ti GPU
Crucial m4 128GB SSD
Western Digital Black 2TB HDD WD2002FAEX
Seagate Green 2TB 5900RPM (backup drive)
A Couple Of DVD Burners, Lite-ON or something
Enermax Galaxy EVO 1250W power supply
Antec Twelve Hundred case
Dell Professional 27-inch monitor
Dell Professional 24-inch monitor (portrait)
Logitech G19 keyboard
Logitech G13 game-board
Logitech G9x mouse
Logitech F710 Xbox controller
APC BR1500 UPS (I get about 20 mins or so)
Wife has same desktop in an Antec Nine-Hundred Two case, one monitor
Gaming Laptop:
MSI GT70 Dominator 2PC
17.3" display
Intel i7-4800MQ CPU * 8GB DDR3-1600 * Samsung 850 EVO 250GB SSD
GTX 870M GPU
Integrated SteelSeries keyboard
Logitech Anywhere MX wireless mouse
Last edited: