Security News The Internet's ...worst nightmare

Victor M

Level 28
Verified
Top Poster
Well-known
Content source
https://xkcd.com/2347/
dependency.png
 
Hi Victor — the classic xkcd “Dependency” cartoon is funny because it captures a genuine software supply-chain risk: critical systems may inherit obscure, transitive dependencies maintained by one overworked volunteer.

The real nightmare is not open source itself, but unknown dependencies with no redundancy or maintenance plan. Sensible mitigations include:

  • maintaining a software bill of materials (SBOM);
  • pinning, reviewing and monitoring dependencies;
  • removing abandoned packages;
  • using signed releases and reproducible builds where possible;
  • funding critical maintainers and preparing supported forks.

In short, redundancy for servers is routine; redundancy for the people maintaining their foundations is still strangely optional.
 
From ChatGPT: (also proves that chat can understand cartoons)

find that person in fictitious nebraska from fictitious 2003

The cartoon is a joke about software dependency chains: modern digital infrastructure depends on a tiny, obscure software project that one volunteer in Nebraska has maintained since 2003.
The person isn't identified in the cartoon, and Nebraska and 2003 are part of the joke, not clues to a documented individual.
However, there are real developers who fit this description remarkably well. I'll look for the closest real-world examples.

The closest real-world matches​

DeveloperProjectWhy they fit
John CristyImageMagickThe strongest clue: the cartoon's author explicitly mentions ImageMagick in its hidden caption.
Lasse CollinXZ UtilsMaintained an essential Linux compression project for years with limited resources. It became the target of a major supply-chain attack in 2024.
Denis Pushkarevcore-jsLongtime maintainer of a JavaScript library used indirectly by enormous numbers of websites and applications.
Chet RameyGNU BashHas maintained Bash for decades, making him another striking example of a critical project depending heavily on one person.

The most interesting finding is the original cartoon's hidden caption:
Someday ImageMagick will finally break for good and we'll have a long period of scrambling as we try to reassemble civilization from the rubble.
That's from xkcd #2347 — Dependency, published August 17, 2020.
It makes John Cristy and ImageMagick particularly relevant, although the cartoon is not explicitly identifying Cristy as the Nebraska developer.
The XZ Utils incident is perhaps the clearest cybersecurity demonstration of the cartoon's warning. A malicious contributor gained maintainer privileges and inserted a backdoor that could have compromised SSH authentication. Developer Andres Freund discovered it in March 2024 before it reached widespread stable deployment.
Ars Technica+1
Conclusion: There is no verified actual Nebraska person from 2003 to find. But there are identifiable developers maintaining foundational software with surprisingly little support. The cartoon describes a genuine software supply-chain security problem, not merely an amusing hypothetical.
 
Last edited:

MalwareTips community

Join the discussion

Create a free account to reply to this thread, ask your own questions and get help from the community.

  • Reply and ask questions
  • Get alerts when someone answers
  • Free malware removal help

Join 75,667 members who help each other for free, since 2010.

Create free account
or continue with

Recently browsing

Members and guests who viewed this thread in the last 5 minutes

Back
Top