What in god's name is going on with Emsisoft Anti Malware?

Status
Not open for further replies.

Emsisoft

From Emsisoft
Verified
Developer
Jul 27, 2013
43
Terri Ganzi, sorry to say but you should first learn how the software works before you start drawing any misleading and wrong conclusions.

Our products use Bitdefender + our own scan engine. Our first goal is to provide the best overall protection, while in the end it doesn't matter at all which engine detected a specific threat. Our second goal is to keep resource usage and memory consumption as low as possible. Which means we have to avoid loading two full scan engines, as they would require more than 500 MB of RAM and slow down the computer. However, since we are in full control over the sourcecode of our own one only, we can only apply modifications to our own part.

More precisely: We continuously check which threats are already detected by Bitdefender and disable all signatures in our own engine that were created to detect the same threats. At the moment we have own signatures for about 85 million different types of malware, but only about 1-2 million signatures are actively distributed via online updates to our software clients.

As a result you of course will see 99% "(B)" detections when scanning large malware archives. That's because we focus on the tiny delta on top of Bitdefender (which does a quite good job btw). Our own signatures mostly focus on brand new outbreaks. Hours later Bitdefender then usually publishes the same signatures so we can disable ours again.

If you really want to compare detection, get some brand new malware samples that are not yet shared across the whole antivirus industry and check which products are able to stop them. Tony Cole did an awesome real world test on Emsisoft Anti-Malware 9 beta lately: http://malwaretips.com/media/emsisoft-anti-malware-9-beta-youtube.61/
 

BoraMurdar

Super Moderator
Verified
Staff Member
Well-known
Aug 30, 2012
6,598
15x64hl.jpg
 

Moose

Level 22
Jun 14, 2011
2,271
> :confused:
> Blame Umbra Polaris for what?
> With Microsoft, Windows 8.1 & Emsisoft?
> Not sure about this printed material, where is this printed?
> Escape Goat for who & why?
> Name calling and Profiling,why?
> Umbra Polaris is also, on Wilder Security ect....
> Labeling of MalwareTips?


Can some answer the above questions?
 
Last edited:

BoraMurdar

Super Moderator
Verified
Staff Member
Well-known
Aug 30, 2012
6,598
> :confused:
> Blame Umbra Polaris for what?
> With Microsoft, Windows 8.1 & Emsisoft?
> Not sure about this printed material, where is this printed?
> Escape Goat for who & why?
> Name calling and Profiling,why?
> Umbra Polaris is also, on Wilder Security ect....
> Labeling of MalwareTips?

Can some answer the above questions?
It's a joke :D

Fake newsletter template, don't take it serious ;)
 

Rahadian Putra

Level 9
Verified
Well-known
Jan 28, 2014
444

Now this is interesting,after reading this I told my neighbor, he is Frodo, he said he's gonna help Gandalf to break Umbra's spell. It's not an easy task he said! since Umbra is Sauron's apprentice and descendant of mordor :eek::p

Emsisoft is great product by the way, I like it how emsisoft using dual engine along with BD engine, what emsisoft's staff mentioned above is also explained my curiousity, thanks! :)
 

Terry Ganzi

Level 26
Thread author
Verified
Top Poster
Well-known
Feb 7, 2014
1,540
Well guys i'm in my father's G7 plane to meet with the parties at an undisclosed location where things could get sticky icky or go down smooth, at least that what the ladies in stilettos & mini skirts that i'm bringing are looking forward to cheers peeps:)
 

Ink

Administrator
Verified
Jan 8, 2011
22,490
At the moment we have own signatures for about 85 million different types of malware, but only about 1-2 million signatures are actively distributed via online updates to our software clients.

I never knew this. Are the unused signatures used by your cloud network?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Terry Ganzi

nsm0220

Level 21
Verified
Sep 9, 2013
1,054
you know that gdata already found a to keep their ram usage to 30-40 mb of ram so why not if you so worry about loading two full scan engines, as you claim they would require more than 500 MB of RAM and slow down the computer do some do some trial and error on your am software
 

Nightwalker

Level 24
Verified
Honorary Member
Top Poster
Content Creator
Well-known
May 26, 2014
1,339
you know that gdata already found a to keep their ram usage to 30-40 mb of ram so why not if you so worry about loading two full scan engines, as you claim they would require more than 500 MB of RAM and slow down the computer do some do some trial and error on your am software

Antivirus performance or memory usage should never be measured by Task Manager alone, almost all antivirus solutions nowdays "cheat" using Windows Page File or they hide the real usage using some OS mechanisms.

For me this is stupid and it hurts performance, Eset and Emisisoft are among the few players that are honest about their memory usage and are fast because they actually use RAM memory to keep signatures.

In the end performance it is what matters, not fake ram usage, it is hilarious to see people thinking that their antivirus only use 20 ~ 40 mb (except cloud antivirus solutions). The engine and database should be loaded somewhere right ? ;)
 

nsm0220

Level 21
Verified
Sep 9, 2013
1,054
Antivirus performance or memory usage should never be measured by Task Manager alone, almost all antivirus solutions nowdays "cheat" using Windows Page File or they hide the real usage using some OS mechanisms.

For me this is stupid and it hurts performance, Eset and Emisisoft are among the few players that are honest about their memory usage and are fast because they actually use RAM memory to keep signatures.

In the end performance it is what matters, not fake ram usage, it is hilarious to see people thinking that their antivirus only use 20 ~ 40 mb (except cloud antivirus solutions). The engine and database should be loaded somewhere right ? ;)
fake ram usage what you talking about and us av reviewers always use task manager to see how much ram usage that an av takes up
 

Nightwalker

Level 24
Verified
Honorary Member
Top Poster
Content Creator
Well-known
May 26, 2014
1,339
fake ram usage what you talking about and us av reviewers always use task manager to see how much ram usage that an av takes up

You and some Av reviewers are simple doing it wrong, you should use something like Process Explorer and examine Working Set and Private Working Set (not enough for some Av ).

Please take a look here

https://www.raymond.cc/blog/which-free-antivirus-is-the-lightest-on-system-memory-usage/


In Wilders Security forum there are many threads about this, I will post the links soon ...
 
D

Deleted member 178

fake ram usage what you talking about and us av reviewers always use task manager to see how much ram usage that an av takes up

and you do wrong; RAM usage must be taken just as an indicator not the real resources usage; for example ; Webroot's processes use very few Mb of RAM but the pagefile usage is around 300mb ; of course the system responsiveness is not much affected but my RAM is still ate up. Why do you think i removed WSA from my setup.

testing AV is not just throwing bunch of malwares against an AV but to know the product in a deeper level. if i wanted i could do 1000+ review a year but i do very few because if i have to do a test, i need to know the product very well in all aspects and it will take more than a month for each.

i prefer be a closed-beta tester than a malware-tester; at least i know all implication of the software; and devs give me answers to my feedbacks in a accurate level since they need my feedbacks to improve their product.

it is ok to test malware but if you draw quick conclusions after the said product fails against one of them , you are wrong, you have to know why the product failed and doing a report to the support and ask for a reason ; ONLY THEN you can issue a statement.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

About us

  • MalwareTips is a community-driven platform providing the latest information and resources on malware and cyber threats. Our team of experienced professionals and passionate volunteers work to keep the internet safe and secure. We provide accurate, up-to-date information and strive to build a strong and supportive community dedicated to cybersecurity.

User Menu

Follow us

Follow us on Facebook or Twitter to know first about the latest cybersecurity incidents and malware threats.

Top