Question DNS rebinding attacks

Please provide comments and solutions that are helpful to the author of this topic.
ControlD free has no settings; it is similar to Adguard free without account (with account, AG free is customizable, such as NextDNS).
It doesn't but I meant configure it as in set it up on your PC. I edited my post with few basic, simple steps by which you can test why ControlD doesn't protect you from DNS rebinding attacks.
 
It doesn't but I meant configure it as in set it up on your PC. I edited my post with few basic, simple steps by which you can test why ControlD doesn't protect you from DNS rebinding attacks.
It is not ControlD fault, all those without settings failed the test; to pass, must use dns with settings including dns rebind protection; I'm sure controld paid will pass.
 
It is not ControlD fault, all those without settings failed the test; to pass, must use dns with settings including dns rebind protection; I'm sure controld paid will pass.
It's not ControlD's fault because then it wouldn't work for me and everyone else. As I said, it's either Edge acting up or your PC. Go to dnscheck.tools; maybe there's DNS leak on your end.
 
Try to test with a portable browser, that will help you to determine whether it caused by the browser and it's settings or extensions or by Windows or another app like AV.
That's what I do. Whenever I have an issue, I download portable web browser and test if same issue occurs in it too.
 
If the browser the culprit, why the test passed with the exact same browser but with a different dns provider?
Might be saved cookies, browser's cache, some special config. AdguardDNS partially blocks ControlD, something like that could interfere with the test.

capture_11292025_141449.jpg

You could enable origin settings, not sure if it affects DNS rebinding, but it is worth a try.

capture_11292025_141337.jpg
 
ControlD Free DNS (HaGeZi Pro Plus) absolutely passes this test on my PC. I'm connecting through my Asus router (which is behind the NAT of ISP issued router Huawei).

View attachment 293325
Control D Free Hagezi Pro also passes the test here. I'm curious, do you find false positives with the Pro Plus?
 
If the browser the culprit, why the test passed with the exact same browser but with a different dns provider?
If Edge doesn't pass, I'd download Chrome Portable and try in it. In case DNS rebinding protection works in Chrome with ControlD, then God knows what Edge is doing with DNS. It's a question for them, not us, as DoH implementation differs from browser to browser. Firefox has terrible DoH implementation for example.
I'm curious, do you find false positives with the Pro Plus?
Maybe one or two, reported to GitHub and it was fixed promptly. I found more false positives with other block lists; barely any with HaGeZi which is why I stick to it.
 
AdguardDNS partially blocks ControlD
Actually AG free dns (customizable with account) passed the test provided by ControlD; ControlD free dns is the one which failed the test provided by ControlD.
In addition, NextDNS passed the test; it is not cookies issue; it is simple, NextDNS and AG dns (with account) have the option of dns rebinding protection to be enabled.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Sampei.Nihira
I will try Chrome, but not the portable; here I compare nonportable edge with nonportable chrome; if I get the same results, then it is certainly not a browser issue, but a dns one.
Have you tried Firefox Portable? Does it work there? If it doesn't work in Firefox, it's something system-level in question. Can't be DNS because it we'd have the same issue.

Brave works for me too:

Screenshot_2.png
 
In case DNS rebinding protection works in Chrome with ControlD, then God knows what Edge is doing with DNS.
Chromium browsers leak via unencrypted DNS, when it is blocked, Edge causes 5 secs delay every 5 mins (DNS Cache). I reported it 3 years ago, still no fix.
 

Attachments

  • capture_11292025_145411.jpg
    capture_11292025_145411.jpg
    262.5 KB · Views: 35
That's bad. Is it just Edge or other Chromium browsers as well?
Well, I should correct myself, Chrome based browsers, the leak affects Chrome, Brave, Edge, but not Chromium. Clearly a bonus tracking feature added afterwards.
 

Attachments

  • capture_11292025_150245.jpg
    capture_11292025_150245.jpg
    263.3 KB · Views: 30
Well, I should correct myself, Chrome based browsers, the leak affects Chrome, Brave, Edge, but not Chromium. Clearly a bonus tracking feature added afterwards.
Aha, so that explains why DoH response time in Firefox is slower than in Chromium based browsers. I have this setting disabled because when I use ControlD Setup Utility for system-wide DoH3, response time is 30ms.

Screenshot_1.png

View attachment 293335

I had to allow it, otherwise it would be blocked by default because it was not on the TLD list:

View attachment 293336
It's always a good idea to turn off ad blockers on testing sites to get accurate results.
 

You may also like...