Tech News Italy Fines Meta €805 Million Over a Facebook Feature That Scanned Android Camera Rolls

lokamoka820

Level 58
Verified
Top Poster
Well-known
Italy's data protection authority, the Garante Privacy, has fined Meta €805 million, about $887 million, over a Facebook feature that accessed the photos and videos of Android users without proper permission. It is the largest penalty the Italian regulator has ever issued.

The fine targets a Facebook feature called "Get camera roll suggestions when you're browsing Facebook." Available since 2023, it suggests photos and videos from the Android camera roll as ideas for new posts.

Why Italy Fined Meta​

The regulator opened its investigation in July 2025 after a report from the consumer protection organization Centro Tutela Consumatori Utenti of Bolzano, and ran its own technical analysis of the app. It concluded that the feature broke Italy's privacy code, which implements the European ePrivacy Directive, and Article 122 of the Italian Data Protection Code. The regulator found that:
  • Facebook asked for camera roll access with a single, app wide permission
  • the permission came after a vague notice to "enable other features" that did not mention camera roll suggestions
  • the feature was turned on by default
  • around 20 million Italian Android users were affected
When granted in full, this kind of permission lets the app read the entire photo library on the device, usually permanently, without the user or the regulator being able to check what is actually used.

The Garante says Article 122 protects the smartphone as part of a person's private sphere, so any access to its contents needs free and informed consent, whether or not data is transmitted or harm occurs. Users who have not updated the Facebook app, or who already granted the permission, are still affected.

Meta argued that the Irish data protection authority should handle the case. The Garante rejected this, because the ePrivacy rules have no one stop shop mechanism. The case did not cover whether the photos were used to train AI, which Meta denies, and the Garante says it will examine a newer feature from 2026 that processes camera roll content in the cloud separately.

The Garante says Meta did not fully cooperate during the investigation, and that this contributed to the size of the fine, along with the number of users affected and a previous 2019 decision against the company.
 
Hi lokamoka820, this is a significant ruling, but one distinction matters: Facebook did not bypass Android’s permission system. Users had granted a device-level photo permission. The Garante’s finding was that this broad permission did not amount to free, informed and specific consent for a separate camera-roll suggestion feature that was enabled by default. An operating-system prompt is not a blank cheque for every feature an app later attaches to it.

The Garante’s decision says Facebook could query the gallery index, identify recently added media and select an item for a posting suggestion. Full Android media permission technically allowed access to the entire shared media library, but that capability does not by itself prove that Meta uploaded the whole library, used it for AI training or caused identifiable harm. The newer cloud-processing feature is outside this proceeding and will be examined separately.

The corrective order is arguably more important than the headline fine. Meta must make the feature off by default, obtain separate and clearly explained consent, and address users who previously granted broad access. The Garante says the €805 million represents about 0.47% of Meta’s worldwide turnover. Meta has said it will appeal, arguing that users already granted a revocable device permission.

For Android users who do not want Facebook browsing their gallery:

  1. Open Android Settings → Apps → Facebook → Permissions → Photos and videos.
  2. Select Don’t allow, or Selected photos where supported.
  3. Check Facebook’s settings for camera-roll sharing suggestions and switch them off.
  4. Keep the app updated, since the regulator says some older versions remain affected.

Removing the permission may make photo-upload features less convenient, but it is the clearest device-level control. This is a privacy and consent case, not evidence that the Facebook app was malware.

Sources
 
This is a privacy and consent case, not evidence that the Facebook app was malware.
Technical nitty gritty. It is borderline malware. Facebook will DO ANYTHING to make itself popular. Your privacy ? ha - we take what we want.
 
Last edited:
Technical nitty gritty. It is borderline malware.


“Borderline malware” is understandable as a criticism, but not a sound technical classification.

The behaviour was privacy-invasive and consent was inadequate: a broad Android permission was reused for a vaguely disclosed, default-enabled feature. That is serious without requiring the malware label. The evidence does not show that Facebook bypassed Android security, exploited the device, or secretly installed a malicious payload.

I would describe it as abusive privacy design or potentially unwanted behaviour. Malware has a more specific meaning, and the technical nitty-gritty is precisely what keeps “software I strongly dislike” from becoming its definition.
 
Instead of investing the money to bypass Android security, they invested the money to bypass humans. The intent is there.
 
Last edited:

MalwareTips community

Join the discussion

Create a free account to reply to this thread, ask your own questions and get help from the community.

  • Reply and ask questions
  • Get alerts when someone answers
  • Free malware removal help

Join 75,660 members who help each other for free, since 2010.

Create free account
or continue with

Recently browsing

Members and guests who viewed this thread in the last 5 minutes

Back
Top