Trend Micro Maximum Security 2015 PCmag review

Discussion in 'Trend Micro' started by Petrovic, Oct 7, 2014.

  1. Petrovic

    Petrovic Level 61
    Trusted

    Apr 25, 2013
    5,268
    19,733
    Somewhere In nowhere
    [​IMG]

    When I challenged Trend Micro to protect a virtual machine test system from my current collection of malware samples, it wiped out 66 percent of them on sight. It whacked quite a few more when I tried to launch them. Its detection rate of 89 percent and overall score of 8.9 put it in between F-Secure Internet Security 2015 and Bitdefender Total Security 2015.

    I tested the product's ability to block malicious URLs using newly-discovered URLs supplied by MRG-Effitas. When initially tested, Trend Micro's 80 percent blocking rate for malicious URLs was a new high score. However, a few days later it was deposed by McAfee AntiVirus Plus 2015, which blocked 85 percent. Both scores are impressive, given that the current average is 32 percent.Symantec Norton Security, tested simultaneously with Trend Micro, managed to block 51 percent.

    A full scan of my standard test system took just 20 minutes. Because Trend Micro avoids re-scanning files already found to be safe, a repeat scan finished in less than a minute.

    Trend Micro's impressive handling of malicious URLs also carried over to my test of its phishing protection ability. Its detection rate lagged just 4 percentage points behind that of Norton. Very few products come close to Norton's fraud detection rate.

    Small Performance Hit
    I wondered whether the additional installation of the password manager, safe browser, vault, and especially SafeSync would make this suite more of a resource eater than Trend Micro's entry level suite. In fact, its scores in my performance tests were the same, within a percent or two.

    My boot time test, which measures the time from the start of the boot process (as reported by Windows) until the system is ready for use took 31 percent longer with this suite installed than with no suite. Given that most people rarely reboot more than once per day, this probably won't be noticeable.

    A script that moves and copies many large files took 7 percent longer with Trend Micro watching. That's actually a bit better than the current average of 9 percent. And another script that repeatedly zips and unzips those files took 13 percent longer, just a little above the current average of 10 percent.

    There are definitely suites with lower overall impact. Webroot's average impact across my three tests was just 3 percent. F-Secure and Bitdefender averaged 4 percent. Even so, I doubt you'll be able to perceive any system slowdown after installing Trend Micro.

    Sub-Ratings:
    Note: These sub-ratings contribute to a product's overall star rating, as do other factors, including ease of use in real-world testing, bonus features, and overall integration of features.
    Firewall: n/a
    Antivirus: [​IMG]
    Performance: [​IMG]
    Antispam: [​IMG]
    Privacy: [​IMG]
    Parental Control: [​IMG]


    Full Article
     
    McLovin, amz, venustus and 1 other person like this.
  2. Tony Cole

    Tony Cole Level 27

    May 11, 2014
    1,619
    3,430
    Emergency medicine ST3
    UK
    Windows 10
    Kaspersky
    Hi Petrovic

    Thanks for the info. How good is PCMag in-terms-of antivirus testing?

    Tony :)
     
    Petrovic likes this.
  3. Petrovic

    Petrovic Level 61
    Trusted

    Apr 25, 2013
    5,268
    19,733
    Somewhere In nowhere
    Good enough
     
  4. Sr. Normal

    Sr. Normal Guest

    As good as Malware Test or Manzai or Nsm0220 ?.
    Here we are accustomed to very high quality.
    a greeting
     
  5. Cch123

    Cch123 Level 7

    May 6, 2014
    332
    815
    I think he does it better because of the resources he has access to. Firstly, he has direct contact with the employees of the antivirus he is testing, which can clear up any confusion etc. Secondly, instead of just testing a short list of some random malware URL, he is supplied by MRG Effitas, where the URLs are extremely fresh and he test a 100 of them.

    Though I must admit that he should reveal the source of his malware pack to be more credible.

    Cheers.
     
    normalizerx likes this.
  6. Sr. Normal

    Sr. Normal Guest

    Thanks for the clarification . Makes sense .
    Kind regards
     
  7. McLovin

    McLovin Level 61
    Trusted AV Tester

    Apr 17, 2011
    8,768
    6,392
    I stream ✌
    Queensland, Australia
    Windows 10
    Trend Micro
    I have all products of Trend on, their password manager, SafeSync. As for their parental controls, they are in a separate program called Trend Micro Online Guardian. As for a firewall it has a built in Windows Firewall booster, which strengthens the firewall. As for performance, I guess it depends on the machine you have, having a decent PC and RAM etc, you won't experience compared to others.

    Great review none the less!
     
    Petrovic likes this.
  8. JAMESWT

    JAMESWT Level 38

    Apr 7, 2014
    2,739
    13,723
    IT Manager
    I don't think so ..... TrendMicro?
    this is my opinion http://malwaretips.com/threads/2015-02-01-kelihos-simda-161-update21.41243/page-6#post-342932
    Sorry
     
Loading...
Similar Threads Forum Date
Help Me Decide Trend Micro Maximum Security vs Emsisoft Antimalware vs Bitdefender Total Security Compare Apps Nov 24, 2017
Help Me Decide F-Secure SAFE vs Trend Micro Maximum Security (v11) Compare Apps Archive Oct 1, 2016
Review Trend Micro Maximum Security 2017 (11.0) Users Review Sep 27, 2016