Poll What are uBlockOrigin users going to do when Google Manifest 3 will be implemented

[ForgottenSeer 107474]

Just wondering what the thoughts are what uBlockOrigin users are going to do when their favourite extension is phased piy due to Mv3 implementation.

I allowed for two choices to facilitate people having a primary and secondary browser approach

I switched from Edge as primary with no adblocker and Chrome as secondary with uBO to Chrome as Primary with AdGuard and Brave as secondary with none. To be honest the increasing addition of non primary browser functionality of Edge also helped to switch browsers.

Apology for the writing error "(or already have to switched)" should be "(or already have switched)", but I can't change the text anymore.

 

[JustInTime]

Just wondering what the thoughts are what uBlockOrigin users are going to do when their favourite extension is phased piy due to Mv3 implementation.

I allowed for two choices to facilitate people having a primary and secondary browser approach

Your question should be for Chrome/Chromium users not for uBlock Origin users. Also Brave will be supporting mv2 as far as I know. If one just doesn't want to drop Chrome for whatever reason AdGuard MV3 is better choice than ublock lite right now.

 

[ForgottenSeer 107474]

Your question should be for Chrome/Chromium users not for uBlock Origin users. Also Brave will be supporting mv2 as far as I know.

Good point you are making but ...

That is also not 100% correct because AdBlock, AdGuard, Badger or Ghostery users won't have to change on Chromium because these developers have said they will adopt their extension to Mv3

and....

In the past browsers always adopted to the WWW-standards, so even the browsers now saying they will keep facilitating Mv2 won't be doing that forever (only to lure users from Chrome to their browser, it is most likely just a marketing tactic to attract more users)

 

[JustInTime]

That is also not 100% correct because AdBlock, AdGuard, Badger or Ghostery users won't have to change on Chromium because these developers have said they will adopt their extension to Mv3

If adopting to mv3 is the point than ublock also has adopted to mv3, so can we also assume ublock users won't have to change. Many other adblock users will also switch if mv3 blockers aren't effective. Just add one more option of "Wasn't using Chrome anyway".

 

[Jan Willy]

How about the desktop version of Adguard and DNS filtering?

 

[Gandalf_The_Grey]

Will go to AdGuard (MV3) or uBlockLite.
The one that will work best for me...
Don't like desktop versions, prefer browser extensions.

 

[ForgottenSeer 107474]

If adopting to mv3 is the point than ublock also has adopted to mv3, so can we also assume ublock users won't have to change. Many other adblock users will also switch if mv3 blockers aren't effective. Just add one more option of "Wasn't using Chrome anyway".

1. uBOL does not have the same functionality than uBo (needs an additional filtering engine).
2. Again you got a point so added this option (wasn't using chrome, so I am not going to be affected by it)

 

[ForgottenSeer 107474]

How about the desktop version of Adguard and DNS filtering?

Added this realistic option , had forgotten this option, because I (like @Gandalf) I prefer an extension

 

[Back3]

How about the desktop version of Adguard and DNS filtering?

I still use uBlock Origin for Librewolf and already switched to Adguard for desktop and DNS filtering with ControlD Malware for everything else… Using Safe to Open online security extension for Chrome and Edge. Will check future tests before deciding to keep that one.

 

[ForgottenSeer 107474]

I still use uBlock Origin for Librewolf and already switched to Adguard for desktop and DNS filtering with ControlD Malware for everything else… Using Safe to Open online security for Chrome and Edge. Will check future tests before deciding to keep that one.

There are two votes possible, I added AdGuard desktop with DNS

 

[Pat MacKnife]

Think Will go to uBlockLite, but mostly using Edge as default browser (is edge also going to use mv3 too ???

 

[Gandalf_The_Grey]

Think Will go to uBlockLite, but mostly using Edge as default browser (is edge also going to use mv3 too ???

Yes, Edge will use mv3 too:

We are currently in the process of updating our MV3 migration timelines.

We are aware that Chromium has revised the timelines for Manifest V2 sunset. We will independently decide on MV3 migration timelines for Microsoft Edge Add-ons and share an update here. We continue to analyze the concerns raised by the extension developers and explore the optimal path for Microsoft Edge Add-ons ecosystem. Meanwhile, please refer to the Chromium timelines for planning your extension's migration.

Overview and timelines for migrating to Manifest V3 - Microsoft Edge Development

Migrating from Manifest V2 to V3 will help reduce fragmentation of the web for developers and enhance privacy, security, and performance for end users. This article covers the overview and timelines for migration from Manifest V2 to V3.

learn.microsoft.com

 

[oldschool]

is edge also going to use mv3 too ???

Definitely.

 

[Gandalf_The_Grey]

Eventually all browsers and extensions will migrate to MV3.
Even Firefox:

The Manifest V3 changes apply to extensions for Safari, Firefox, and Chromium-based browsers – such as Chrome, Edge, and Opera. While the goal is to maintain a high degree of compatibility between the Firefox, Safari, and Chromium extension platforms, our implementation diverges where we think it matters and where our values point to a different direction.

Manifest V3 migration guide

Migrate your extension to Manifest V3. A comprehensive guide to understanding and implementing the necessary changes for your extension.

extensionworkshop.com

 

[oldschool]

Eventually all browsers and extension will migrate to MV3.
Even Firefox:

Manifest V3 migration guide

Migrate your extension to Manifest V3. A comprehensive guide to understanding and implementing the necessary changes for your extension.

extensionworkshop.com

I suspect that Brave user base will continue to increase when the MV3 transition dust has finally settled because it may be the only option for users who want to use custom filter lists. You can see this trend happening now.
AV-Comparatives - IT Security Survey 2024

 

[Gandalf_The_Grey]

I suspect that Brave user base will continue to increase when the MV3 transition dust has finally settled because it may be the only option for users who want to use custom filter lists. You can see this trend happening now.
AV-Comparatives - IT Security Survey 2024

There will be some increase, but only from privacy and security conscious people.
Most will just use Chrome, Edge or Safari (default browser on their device) without any adblocker and don't notice this transition.

 

[Virtuoso]

I will be moving to Adguard extension, their MV3 version will be much better than Ublock Lite which is intentionally gimped and does not make full use of MV3 rules for some ideological reasons. Adguard will be able to block Youtube Ads even after moving to MV3 as they will be using Dynamic rules.

 

[ForgottenSeer 107474]

Eventually all browsers and extensions will migrate to MV3.
Even Firefox:

Manifest V3 migration guide

Migrate your extension to Manifest V3. A comprehensive guide to understanding and implementing the necessary changes for your extension.

extensionworkshop.com

I think so to

 

[South Park]

I've been using uBO Lite on the built-in Edge browser for several months, combined w/ PopUpOff. It's adequate, but not as good as uBO in Firefox, mainly because it lacks user filters and an element zapper. OTOH, I find it easier to block autoplay videos in Edge than on Firefox, so I have less need of the zapper on Edge.

 

[Alexai]

So, uBlock Origin will stop to function?