Advice Request Would this config be overkill; OSArmor, VoodooShield, and Windows Defender?

[LukeLovesSecurity]

Would it be a good idea to use OSArmor, VoodooShield, and Windows Defender? If not, what should I remove or replace?

 

[Gandalf_The_Grey]

Dan the creator of VoodooShield was impressed by OSArmor and said that there was no problem running them side by side. I personally have stopped using VS because I found it too chatty and not completely stable at times.
Inspired by @Nightwalker I'm using Window defender (tweaked for maximum protection by @Andy Ful s Configure Defender, Comodo Firewall tweaked with @cruelsister s settings and OSArmor at default settings.
I'm at to moment very pleased with this setup.

So the short answer is: no there is no overkill.

 

[askmark]

Would it be a good idea to use OSArmor, VoodooShield, and Windows Defender? If so, what should I remove or replace?

Why not? I use them all, plus ERP 4, and have no problems.

The only issue is OSArmor has so many options, it's a pain to know what will or won't work with your system, without some trial and error. Personally, I enable all options and then use "Passive Logging" to identify from my daily workflow what processes/actions/tasks need an exclusion rule.

 

[show-Zi]

I think that the combination is not bad.
As @a skmark says, OSAmor may be necessary to persevere as it goes into details as it sets it seriously.

 

[bribon77]

I do not see it as excessive, OSArmor by default is fine as antiexploit, VoodooShield, as antiexe, and Windows defiender as antivirus.

 

[Electr0n]

No, it won't be an overkill at all, rather it would be a a fine lightweight yet powerful setup.

 

[L0ckJaw]

Using OSArmour with G-Data, encounterd no problems at all.

 

[ZeroDay]

Dan the creator of VoodooShield was impressed by OSArmor and said that there was no problem running them side by side. I personally have stopped using VS because I found it too chatty and not completely stable at times.
Inspired by @Nightwalker I'm using Window defender (tweaked for maximum protection by @Andy Ful s Configure Defender, Comodo Firewall tweaked with @cruelsister s settings and OSArmor at default settings.
I'm at to moment very pleased with this setup.

So the short answer is: no there is no overkill.

Same setup as me minus the OSArmour. My system is running great with this setup.

 

[mekelek]

you good, not a fan of WD, probably the heaviest of all 3