Poll What's your favorite Ad Blocker?

What's your favorite Ad Blocker?

  • AdGuard Browser extension

    Votes: 7 7.5%
  • AdGuard for Windows

    Votes: 19 20.4%
  • uBlock Origin

    Votes: 34 36.6%
  • uBlock Origin Lite

    Votes: 16 17.2%
  • uBol-stripped

    Votes: 2 2.2%
  • Ghostery

    Votes: 3 3.2%
  • ABP

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Other

    Votes: 6 6.5%
  • My browser's built-in Ad Blocker

    Votes: 6 6.5%
  • I don't use an Ad Blocker

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Total voters
    93
Currently, the What's New page doesn't have any Reddit embedded content issues. It's been like this for many days now, I think. Have you checked recently?
Yes, I noticed that. Currently, the "Status Updates" page is causing the issue. Generally, this happens with ad blockers when a page contains embedded content from other major platforms, and you never know when a member might post something similar. I tested AdGuard, Ghostery, and uBlock Origin, and all exhibited the same problem due to the "EasyPrivacy" list. When this list is disabled, no issues occur.
 
and all exhibited the same problem due to the "EasyPrivacy" list.
I have tracking protection disabled all the time, keeping only ads protection.
I can be easily achieved in Brave, uBO, AG, and Ghostery; in uBOL, uBO filters are bundled together, so I have to keep tracking protection of uBO after disabling easyprivacy.
 
Yes, I noticed that. Currently, the "Status Updates" page is causing the issue. Generally, this happens with ad blockers when a page contains embedded content from other major platforms, and you never know when a member might post something similar. I tested AdGuard, Ghostery, and uBlock Origin, and all exhibited the same problem due to the "EasyPrivacy" list. When this list is disabled, no issues occur.
I see. I think the only solution is to disable all embedded contents 🤔
I will try asking Alex of AdGuard or Yuki to see if they can do something about it without compromising privacy or disabling embedded contents. But then again, I think the filter maintainers are already aware of this.
 
I'm not considering disabling tracking protection in the ad blocker; I'd rather disable embedded content 😉

Yes, indeed.
The filter lists I recommended don’t disable anything.
They would streamline privacy protection, especially if similar network filtering already exists at the DNS level.

But my advice was intended to see if those filter lists,which have fewer rules than EP,would resolve the issue.;)
 
Yes, I noticed that. Currently, the "Status Updates" page is causing the issue. Generally, this happens with ad blockers when a page contains embedded content from other major platforms, and you never know when a member might post something similar. I tested AdGuard, Ghostery, and uBlock Origin, and all exhibited the same problem due to the "EasyPrivacy" list. When this list is disabled, no issues occur.
I found a fix for this for AdGuard Extension (and products).
Code:
||embed.reddit.com/svc/shreddit/events$xhr,redirect=nooptext
This rule prevents the CPU usage on the Status page. So this rule, instead of blocking the request (causing reddit to retry again and again), redirects to a local non-existant resource. So reddit thinks, the request was successfull. It may try once or twice after a minute again but that's it, no repeated attempts every few seconds.

uBO also has such redirect rules but the issue is that, on uBO, redirect means, block and redirect (when a block rule exist in a filter). So uBO not only blocking it, it is blocking it as usual and then redirects if a similar rule is applied (slightly diffrent syntax for uBO).
On AdGuard on the other hand, redirect rules are prioritized over block rules. So it's working perfectly fine with AdGuard and seems like an acceptable solution. I haven't seen any breakage on the page, don't know if it will break something elsewhere.

I don't know if there is any other way to achive this in uBO. I use AdGuard myself, so it's fixed for me.

BTW, I was wondering where those reddit requests are coming from since I see no reddit embedded content there. Turns out the Facebook embedded funny content that user The_King shares often are the source of the requests. Facebook and Reddit? Where is the connection there? It's odd.

Anyway, I will ask Alex-302 of AdGuard about the above AdGuard rule tomorrow to see what he says about it and if there's any downside or if it will break something.
 
Easyprivacy Minified
I wouldn't use minified lists because:

Why did you include AdGuard's Optimize lists but not AdBlock Plus' Minified lists?​

The Minified lists are part of an Adblock Plus-hosted unofficial project that was hardforked from their source lists in August 2019. They are smaller than AdGuard's Optimized lists but lack quality blocking. Because EL and EP are your primary defenses with content blocking, I wouldn't use the Minified lists.
GitHub - yokoffing/filterlists: Collection of blocklists to fill in the gaps

Adguard lists are much more reliable.
 
Last edited:
BTW, I was wondering where those reddit requests are coming from since I see no reddit embedded content there. Turns out the Facebook embedded funny content that user The_King shares often are the source of the requests. Facebook and Reddit? Where is the connection there? It's odd.
I think X (formerly Twitter) embedded content have the same issue too. By the way, you can use Edge's tracking prevention in strict mode to stop all the CPU spikes and view any blocked content on Brave browser if it's installed, as Brave Shields don’t have this issue.
 
I found a fix for this for AdGuard Extension (and products).
Code:
||embed.reddit.com/svc/shreddit/events$xhr,redirect=nooptext
This rule prevents the CPU usage on the Status page. So this rule, instead of blocking the request (causing reddit to retry again and again), redirects to a local non-existant resource. So reddit thinks, the request was successfull. It may try once or twice after a minute again but that's it, no repeated attempts every few seconds.

uBO also has such redirect rules but the issue is that, on uBO, redirect means, block and redirect (when a block rule exist in a filter). So uBO not only blocking it, it is blocking it as usual and then redirects if a similar rule is applied (slightly diffrent syntax for uBO).
On AdGuard on the other hand, redirect rules are prioritized over block rules. So it's working perfectly fine with AdGuard and seems like an acceptable solution. I haven't seen any breakage on the page, don't know if it will break something elsewhere.

I don't know if there is any other way to achive this in uBO. I use AdGuard myself, so it's fixed for me.

BTW, I was wondering where those reddit requests are coming from since I see no reddit embedded content there. Turns out the Facebook embedded funny content that user The_King shares often are the source of the requests. Facebook and Reddit? Where is the connection there? It's odd.

Anyway, I will ask Alex-302 of AdGuard about the above AdGuard rule tomorrow to see what he says about it and if there's any downside or if it will break something.
Have you tried this rule for uBo?
Just a question,where is the Status page?:unsure:

Although I wouldn’t run the test because of my complicated dynamic block + I don’t use EP.
Forgive me, but that’s just how I am,even in school, the simplest things were complicated for me!!:confused::ROFLMAO:

Another reason why it's complicated for me is the current forum layout.

Code:
||embed.reddit.com/svc/shreddit/events$xhr,redirect-rule=noop.txt
 
Question to uBO/uBOL users:

Do threads like the ones below change your mind on the use of extensions (extensions should be treated as third-party code, according to security experts)
  1. A one-click universal XSS issue with uBlock Origin, although a similar but less problematic issue also affected the uBO Lite
  2. The json-edit family scriptlets being able to tamper with data your browser sends out and receives, silently, mid-flight
    After Bot was able to inspect the code, it confirmed the risk and technical capabilities in post #24, #36 and #60
Although above threads proof the risk of being able to inject risky code and being misused because focus of uBO/uBOL is more on speed than security (1) or a supply chain attack (2), is real, the chances of it being misused in real world circumstances are (very very) slim.

On the bright site in all those years nobody has ever misused uBO/uBOL in real world, only two issues were reported (the recent XSS bug on and a $scp bug) in 12 years of world class adblocking using 40K lines of code that is really sound programming. That is 0,05 vulnabilities per KLOC while a value below 0,1 is considered high quality (below 0,01 is considered excellent).

Do you accept it as a normal risk (like the risk of being hit by a bus is very very slim when you cross the street) or do you think (like me) it makes no sense using a highly secured browser (Chrome) and punch holes in it (when ad- and cookie annoyances can be dealt with, without needing these mechanisms)?

---

P.S. when you check above with AI, that is not of much use, because AI assumes that the prevailing opinion is true (like in MT 55% of the voters prefer uBO/uBOL). In simple terms when AI checks something and sees that author 1 of extension A has 10 million users and author 2 of extension B has 500 users, than author 1 has to be right because 10 million users is hard evidence (@Sampei.Nihira - AI would conclude that Galileo was wrong ;)).

Besides this big data preference, AI has two other issues: AI often does not deep check materials and AI has its occasional illusion hickup making weird logic twist (see below examples of botty hallucinating and not-fact checking something).


1794985508864.png


1794985446997.png
 
Last edited:
@LinuxFan58
I'm currently considering relying on DNS-level ad blocking and the browser's built-in ad blocker, as I've found AdGuard, Ghostery, and uBlock Origin have their own issues for me. Unfortunately, uBlock Dynamic isn't available in my region, so I haven't tried it, but all the users who have switched to it are more experienced than me, so I can trust their opinions that it's better.
 
I still use uBO. I understand the argument that any extension adds complexity and introduces some degree of risk, but I also think it's important to consider the risks it helps mitigate. For me, the balance still tips in its favor.

The recently discovered vulnerability is a good reminder that no software is entirely free from flaws, no matter how reputable the project may be.

What I take away from this discussion is the importance of being selective about the extensions we install. Keeping the number of extensions low, and choosing ones that are well-maintained and genuinely necessary, seems like a pretty reasonable approach. 🛡️⚖️
 

MalwareTips community

Join the discussion

Create a free account to reply to this thread, ask your own questions and get help from the community.

  • Reply and ask questions
  • Get alerts when someone answers
  • Free malware removal help

Join 75,680 members who help each other for free, since 2010.

Create free account
or continue with

Recently browsing

Members and guests who viewed this thread in the last 5 minutes

Back
Top