I forgot if it was one their devs or a user who told me on reddit what I shared above. Cosmic simply lacks the ability to remember last window size so it's set to open every app with a fixed size. That's the limitation at the moment and they have plans to implement it later. Basically every popular DE has it so Cosmic will have it too one day.
Yeah it's still kind of in beta but stable enough for most people I assume.
There's one DE that is being developed by one guy which Iooks interesting. It felt to me like how GNOME should have been. But that's being developed only by one person for one Linux Distro at the moment so the future is unclear.